Endo Yasuo, Funayama Hiromi, Yamaguchi Kouji, Monma Yuko, Yu Zhiqian, Deng Xue, Oizumi Takefumi, Shikama Yosuke, Tanaka Yukinori, Okada Satoshi, Kim Siyoung, Kiyama Tomomi, Bando Kanan, Shima Kazuhiro, Suzuki Hikari, Takahashi Tetsu
Divisions of Pharmacology, Graduate School of Dentistry, Tohoku University.
Divisions of Molecular Regulation, Graduate School of Dentistry, Tohoku University.
Yakugaku Zasshi. 2020;140(1):63-79. doi: 10.1248/yakushi.19-00125.
Since the first report in 2003, bisphosphonate-related osteonecrosis of the jaw (BRONJ) has been increasing, without effective clinical strategies. Osteoporosis is common in elderly women, and bisphosphonates (BPs) are typical and widely used anti-osteoporotic or anti-bone-resorptive drugs. BRONJ is now a serious concern in dentistry. As BPs are pyrophosphate analogues and bind strongly to bone hydroxyapatite, and the P-C-P structure of BPs is non-hydrolysable, they accumulate in bones upon repeated administration. During bone-resorption, BPs are taken into osteoclasts and exhibit cytotoxicity, producing a long-lasting anti-bone-resorptive effect. BPs are divided into nitrogen-containing BPs (N-BPs) and non-nitrogen-containing BPs (non-N-BPs). N-BPs have far stronger anti-bone-resorptive effects than non-N-BPs, and BRONJ is caused by N-BPs. Our murine experiments have revealed the following. N-BPs, but not non-N-BPs, exhibit direct and potent inflammatory/necrotic effects on soft-tissues. These effects are augmented by lipopolysaccharide (the inflammatory component of bacterial cell-walls) and the accumulation of N-BPs in jawbones is augmented by inflammation. N-BPs are taken into soft-tissue cells via phosphate-transporters, while the non-N-BPs etidronate and clodronate inhibit this transportation. Etidronate, but not clodronate, has the effect of expelling N-BPs that have accumulated in bones. Moreover, etidronate and clodronate each have an analgesic effect, while clodronate has an anti-inflammatory effect via inhibition of phosphate-transporters. These findings suggest that BRONJ may be induced by phosphate-transporter-mediated and infection-promoted mechanisms, and that etidronate and clodronate may be useful for preventing and treating BRONJ. Our clinical trials support etidronate being useful for treating BRONJ, although additional clinical trials of etidronate and clodronate are needed.
自2003年首次报道以来,双膦酸盐相关颌骨坏死(BRONJ)的病例一直在增加,且尚无有效的临床应对策略。骨质疏松在老年女性中很常见,双膦酸盐(BPs)是典型且广泛使用的抗骨质疏松或抗骨吸收药物。BRONJ如今已成为牙科领域的一个严重问题。由于双膦酸盐是焦磷酸盐类似物,能与骨羟基磷灰石紧密结合,且其P-C-P结构不可水解,反复给药后它们会在骨骼中蓄积。在骨吸收过程中,双膦酸盐被破骨细胞摄取并表现出细胞毒性,产生持久的抗骨吸收作用。双膦酸盐分为含氮双膦酸盐(N-BPs)和不含氮双膦酸盐(非N-BPs)。N-BPs的抗骨吸收作用远比非N-BPs强,而BRONJ是由N-BPs引起的。我们的小鼠实验揭示了以下情况。N-BPs而非非N-BPs,对软组织具有直接且强效的炎症/坏死作用。脂多糖(细菌细胞壁的炎症成分)会增强这些作用,而炎症会增加N-BPs在颌骨中的蓄积。N-BPs通过磷酸盐转运体进入软组织细胞,而非N-BPs依替膦酸和氯膦酸会抑制这种转运。依替膦酸而非氯膦酸,具有排出已蓄积在骨骼中的N-BPs的作用。此外,依替膦酸和氯膦酸各自都有镇痛作用,而氯膦酸通过抑制磷酸盐转运体具有抗炎作用。这些发现表明,BRONJ可能由磷酸盐转运体介导和感染促进机制所诱发,且依替膦酸和氯膦酸可能对预防和治疗BRONJ有用。我们的临床试验支持依替膦酸对治疗BRONJ有用,不过仍需要对依替膦酸和氯膦酸开展更多临床试验。