AlBathi Abdullah K, Shaaban Saeed S, Alshadadi Faisal, Alsheikh Bader, Althinayyan Basim, Khashoggi Khalid, Merdad Mazin
Department of Otolaryngology - Head and Neck Surgery, King Abdulaziz University Hospital, Jeddah, SAU.
Department of Medicine, King Abdulaziz University Hospital, Jeddah, SAU.
Cureus. 2019 Dec 26;11(12):e6473. doi: 10.7759/cureus.6473.
Introduction Foreign body (FB) ingestion is one of the most common complaints presenting at an emergency department (ED), with fish bone impaction being a frequent cause of presentation. Fish bones might be challenging to identify on routine radiography and ED physicians are often left in a state of uneasiness owing to the fear of complications occurring if the fish bone is not removed. Objective This study aimed to establish the factors affecting the radio-opacity of fish bones on X-ray. Materials and methods The study involved the top three fish species consumed on Saudi Arabia's western coast. Fish bones from three specimens of each species were radiographically examined by hand-picking bones from different parts of the fish, with particular attention paid to bones that are difficult to spot. Bones were then arranged beside each other, and radiographs were taken for comparison. Inter-species and intra-species radio-opacity variation was tested. Further, the weight of each fish and method of cooking (baked vs. fried) were tested for their effect on radio-opacity. Results No significant difference in radio-opacity was found among and between different species, and the method of cooking did not alter the radio-opacity of fish bones. Significant differences in radio-opacity were noted with the difference in the diameter and size of the fish bones, which tended to be less radio-opaque in smaller-sized fish, regardless of the species. Conclusion The exact fish species and method of cooking did not alter the fish bone density on an X-ray. The size of the fish and the size of the fish bone are better predictors of higher fish bone density.
引言 异物吞食是急诊科最常见的就诊原因之一,鱼骨嵌顿是常见的就诊原因。常规X线检查可能难以识别鱼骨,急诊科医生往往因担心鱼骨不取出会引发并发症而感到不安。目的 本研究旨在确定影响鱼骨在X射线下不透光性的因素。材料与方法 该研究涉及沙特阿拉伯西海岸食用量排名前三的鱼类品种。从每个品种的三条鱼标本中选取不同部位的鱼骨进行X线检查,特别关注难以发现的鱼骨。然后将鱼骨并排摆放,拍摄X线片进行比较。测试种间和种内不透光性的差异。此外,还测试了每条鱼的重量和烹饪方法(烘焙与油炸)对不透光性的影响。结果 不同品种之间以及品种内部的不透光性均无显著差异,烹饪方法也未改变鱼骨的不透光性。不同直径和大小的鱼骨在不透光性上存在显著差异,无论品种如何,较小尺寸的鱼的鱼骨往往不透光性较差。结论 确切的鱼类品种和烹饪方法不会改变X线下鱼骨的密度。鱼的大小和鱼骨的大小能更好地预测较高的鱼骨密度。