Waldron I
Int J Health Serv. 1977;7(1):37-62. doi: 10.2190/FPJT-V9YE-VWM1-UXPA.
Drug prescriptions per capita in the United States have more than doubled since 1950 without a commensurate improvement in health. Drugs are often prescribed for clinical conditions in which therapeutic benefits do not outweigh the risk of adverse drug reactions. Deaths due to adverse drug reactions are roughly as frequent as deaths due to automobile accidents. Valium and Librium are the first and fourth most commonly prescribed drugs in the U.S., used by one ten adults each year. The rapid rise in use of these drugs has occurred during a period of rising social stress, as indicated by increases in alcohol consumption, suicide, and homicide, Valium and Librium are frequently prescribe for patients who go to doctors with social or other nonmedical problems, often in lieu of attempts to resolve these underlying problems. Overprescribing occurs because the decision to prescribe is influenced not only by consideration of therapeutic benefit, but also by nonmedical factors, for example the widespread expectation by both patient and doctor that the doctor will provide a drug or some other technological treatment. Prescribing decisions are also influenced by the profit-motivated activities of drug companies, including the expenditure of almost one-quarter of every sales dollar on drug promotion. The most widely used source of drug information for doctors is the industry-sponsored Physicians' Desk Reference, which overrates the therapeutic value of Valium and Librium as compared to disinterested medical sources. Drug companies also contribute to overprescribing by introducing numerous minor variants of existing drugs. The therapeutic benefits of such new drugs are often overestimated in the early years of use when adverse side effects are not well known and apparent efficacy is enhanced by placebo effects in uncontrolled observations.
自1950年以来,美国人均药物处方量增加了一倍多,但健康状况却没有相应改善。药物常常被用于治疗那些治疗益处并未超过药物不良反应风险的临床病症。因药物不良反应导致的死亡人数与因汽车事故导致的死亡人数大致相当。安定和利眠宁分别是美国处方量排名第一和第四的药物,每年有十分之一的成年人使用。这些药物使用量的快速增长发生在社会压力不断上升的时期,这一点从酒精消费、自杀和凶杀案的增加中可见一斑。安定和利眠宁经常被开给那些因社会或其他非医疗问题去看医生的患者,常常被用来替代解决这些潜在问题的尝试。过度开药的出现是因为开处方的决定不仅受到治疗益处的考虑影响,还受到非医疗因素的影响,例如患者和医生普遍期望医生会提供药物或其他某种技术治疗。开处方的决定还受到制药公司逐利活动的影响,包括将几乎四分之一的销售额用于药品促销。医生最广泛使用的药物信息来源是由制药行业赞助的《医师案头参考》,与公正的医学资料相比,它高估了安定和利眠宁的治疗价值。制药公司还通过推出现有药物的众多微小变体导致过度开药。在使用这些新药的早期,当不良反应尚不为人所知且在无对照观察中安慰剂效应增强了明显疗效时,这些新药的治疗益处往往被高估。