Lau T, Tos M
ENT Department, Gentofte University Hospital, Hellerup, Denmark.
Arch Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg. 1988 Dec;114(12):1428-34. doi: 10.1001/archotol.1988.01860240078028.
We classified cholesteatomas as attic cholesteatoma, developing from Shrapnell's membrane; tensa cholesteatoma, originating in pars tensa, which is subdivided into tensa retraction cholesteatoma involving the entire pars tensa, and sinus cholesteatomas, developing from a posterosuperior retraction (perforation). From 1964 to 1980, one-stage operations were carried out on 271 ears with sinus cholesteatomas. Follow-up included 90% of the patients, and the median observation time was 9.75 years. The recurrence rate was 10%. The recurrence rate was found to be independent of the mastoidectomy type employed. The best hearing results were obtained in ears with intact ossicular chain. We conclude that, wherever possible, sinus cholesteatoma should be removed through the auditory canal without mastoidectomy just as an intact ossicular chain should be preserved. "Canal wall up" and "canal wall down" appear to be equally valuable mastoidectomy types, and both methods must be employed to obtain optimum results.
我们将胆脂瘤分为上鼓室胆脂瘤,由鼓膜松弛部发展而来;紧张部胆脂瘤,起源于鼓膜紧张部,又细分为累及整个鼓膜紧张部的紧张部内陷胆脂瘤和由后上内陷(穿孔)发展而来的鼓窦胆脂瘤。1964年至1980年,对271例鼓窦胆脂瘤患者的耳朵进行了一期手术。90%的患者接受了随访,中位观察时间为9.75年。复发率为10%。发现复发率与所采用的乳突切除术类型无关。听骨链完整的耳朵听力结果最佳。我们得出结论,只要有可能,鼓窦胆脂瘤应通过耳道切除而不进行乳突切除术,就如同应保留完整的听骨链一样。“上鼓室开放”和“上鼓室封闭”似乎是同样有价值的乳突切除术类型,必须采用这两种方法才能获得最佳效果。