College of Nursing, University of Saskatchewan, Saskatoon, Saskatchewan, S7N 2E5, Canada
Rural Remote Health. 2020 Jan;20(1):5640. doi: 10.22605/RRH5640. Epub 2020 Jan 13.
Recruitment and retention of healthcare providers to rural workplaces is often challenging due to many factors, such as complex work environments requiring a broad skill set, minimal staffing, and limited community support and resources. Mentorship has been proposed as a strategy to encourage recruitment and retention of staff in rural workplaces. This article describes a rural-specific pilot mentorship program that was implemented and evaluated in terms of supporting rural mentorships, easing workplace transition, strengthening community connections, and encouraging recruitment and retention in rural communities.
Thirty volunteer registered nurse mentors and mentees were recruited from within a western Canadian province. These individuals worked in communities with populations of less than 10 000. Mentors and mentees were matched by program coordinators based on self-identified relationship priorities and similar responses to questions including preferred frequency and method of contact. Online orientation to the program was provided and the formal mentorship lasted 4 months. Follow-up program evaluation was conducted via informal electronic feedback and comprehensive interviews that were analyzed using thematic analysis.
Three themes were identified by participants that serve as key considerations when implementing a rural mentorship program: connection, communication, and support. Connection describes the variety of relationships participants formed throughout the mentorship program, including connections to their mentor/mentee, themselves, their profession, colleagues, and the larger rural community. Communication includes the logistics of corresponding between mentee-mentor dyads during the program, participant communication with the coordinators of the program, and future communication about and promotion of rural mentorship programs. Support was described as interpersonal and professional assistance provided to the mentee from the mentor as well as to the mentor from the mentorship program and management. Data from the study suggest that rural-specific mentorships are effective in terms of supporting mentorships, easing workplace transition, strengthening community connections, and encouraging recruitment and retention of registered nurses in rural health care. Pervasive throughout the themes derived from the thematic analysis of interview data was the pivotal role of four key groups (mentors, mentees, the healthcare organization, and the rural community) in developing, facilitating, and sustaining mentorships in rural areas.
Participants in this study believed that mentorship was beneficial to support healthcare providers working in rural environments. However, greater strides need to be made in terms of creating and supporting such relationships. The responsibility for mentorship resides with not only the mentor and mentee but also health organizations and rural communities. Members from all groups need to be committed and contribute to mentorship for rural mentorship programs to be successful and sustainable. Rural residents are often underserved due to insufficient numbers of healthcare professionals working in rural areas along with a limited number of services offered. The greater the numbers of healthcare professionals that can be recruited and retained within rural communities, the greater the likelihood the community residents will have timely and appropriate access to quality health services. These services can result in positive patient outcomes and greater community health.
由于工作环境复杂、人员配置不足、社区支持和资源有限等诸多因素,招聘和留住医疗保健提供者到农村工作场所往往具有挑战性。导师制已被提议作为一种鼓励在农村工作场所招聘和留住员工的策略。本文描述了在加拿大西部一个省份实施和评估的一项农村特定的试点导师制计划,以支持农村导师制、缓解工作场所过渡、加强社区联系,并鼓励农村社区的招聘和留用。
从加拿大西部一个省招募了 30 名志愿注册护士导师和学员。这些人在人口少于 10000 人的社区工作。根据自我确定的关系优先级和对问题的类似回答,包括首选的频率和联系方式,项目协调员为导师和学员进行匹配。提供了在线计划介绍,正式导师制持续了 4 个月。通过非正式的电子反馈和全面的访谈进行了后续的方案评估,并使用主题分析对访谈进行了分析。
参与者确定了三个主题,这些主题是实施农村导师制计划时需要考虑的关键因素:联系、沟通和支持。联系描述了参与者在整个导师制计划中建立的各种关系,包括与导师/学员、自己、自己的职业、同事和更大的农村社区的联系。沟通包括学员-导师二人组在计划期间通信的后勤工作、参与者与计划协调员的通信,以及未来关于农村导师制计划的沟通和推广。支持是指从导师那里为学员提供的人际关系和专业协助,以及从导师制计划和管理层那里为导师提供的支持。研究数据表明,农村特定的导师制在支持导师制、缓解工作场所过渡、加强社区联系以及鼓励农村卫生保健注册护士的招聘和留用方面是有效的。在对访谈数据进行主题分析得出的主题中,始终存在四个关键群体(导师、学员、医疗保健组织和农村社区)在农村地区发展、促进和维持导师制方面的关键作用。
参与这项研究的人认为导师制对支持在农村环境中工作的医疗保健提供者是有益的。然而,在建立和支持这种关系方面还需要做出更大的努力。导师制的责任不仅在于导师和学员,还在于医疗组织和农村社区。所有群体的成员都需要承诺并为导师制做出贡献,以使农村导师制计划取得成功并具有可持续性。由于在农村地区工作的医疗保健专业人员人数不足以及提供的服务有限,农村居民往往得不到足够的服务。在农村社区招聘和留住的医疗保健专业人员越多,社区居民获得及时和适当的优质卫生服务的可能性就越大。这些服务可以带来积极的患者结果和更大的社区健康。