Rehabilitation Sciences Program, University of Brasília, Faculdade de Ceilândia, Brasília, Brazil.
Hospital de Apoio de Brasília, Brazil.
J Voice. 2021 Jul;35(4):545-553. doi: 10.1016/j.jvoice.2019.12.013. Epub 2020 Jan 11.
To analyze and assess studies on the topic and to describe the vocal parameters of patients with traumatic spinal cord injury (SCI) based on the literature.
Studies were identified and selected by searching for articles on the subject published in any journal, using pre-established descriptors: "spinal cord injury," "speech," "lang$," "speech-lang$," and "voice" ("traumatismos da medula espinal," "fala," "fona$," "fonoaud$," and "voz" in Brazilian Portuguese). All the phases of the study were conducted independently by the researchers and in the event of disagreement, a final decision was reached by consensus. The articles selected were critically assessed based on their objectives, treatment, and assessment criteria and methods, results and conclusions, as well their level of scientific evidence.
A total of 70 scientific articles were identified, eight of which were considered valid based on the inclusion criteria. Research on the contribution of speech therapy to patients with SCI is scarce, particularly regarding voice assessment and treatment. Descriptive and observational studies predominated, with a small sample. Data collection was predominated cross-sectional, which made it possible to identify evaluation and intervention techniques, but the methodologies described preclude generalizations. The results indicated that the parameters of the respiratory function and vocal production in patients with traumatic SCI were reduced lung capacity, presence of voice problems, presence of perceived voice problems, and altered activation of accessory respiratory muscle.
The vocal parameters of the patients with traumatic SCI can be described, considering the lack of information available. Disorders related to speech therapy vary in accordance with the type and level of injury. It is important to increase scientific production in this area, particularly randomized trials, in order to establish assessment criteria and treatment techniques and improve levels of evidence.
分析和评估相关研究,描述创伤性脊髓损伤(SCI)患者的嗓音参数。
通过在任何期刊上搜索主题文章,使用预先设定的描述词:“脊髓损伤”、“言语”、“lang$”、“speech-lang$”和“voice”(在巴西葡萄牙语中分别为“traumatismos da medula espinal”、“fala”、“fona$”、“fonoaud$”和“voz”),来识别和选择研究。研究的所有阶段均由研究人员独立进行,如果存在分歧,则通过共识达成最终决定。根据研究目的、治疗方法和评估标准及方法、结果和结论以及科学证据水平对所选文章进行严格评估。
共确定了 70 篇科学文章,其中 8 篇符合纳入标准。关于言语治疗对 SCI 患者的作用的研究很少,特别是关于嗓音评估和治疗。描述性和观察性研究居多,样本量较小。数据采集主要是横断面的,这使得可以识别评估和干预技术,但所描述的方法学限制了其推广应用。结果表明,创伤性 SCI 患者的呼吸功能和发声参数存在肺活量降低、存在嗓音问题、存在感知到的嗓音问题以及辅助呼吸肌激活改变。
可以根据现有信息来描述创伤性 SCI 患者的嗓音参数。与言语治疗相关的障碍因损伤类型和程度而异。重要的是要增加该领域的科学研究,特别是随机试验,以建立评估标准和治疗技术,提高证据水平。