Department of Public and Occupational Health, Amsterdam Public Health research institute, Amsterdam UMC, Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam, Amsterdam, The Netherlands.
Stichting Fibula, Utrecht, The Netherlands.
BMC Palliat Care. 2020 Jan 16;19(1):10. doi: 10.1186/s12904-020-0514-6.
PaTz (palliative care at home) is a method to improve palliative care in the primary care setting in the Netherlands. PaTz has three basic principles: (1) local GPs and DNs meet at least six times per year to identify and discuss their patients with a life-threatening illness; (2) these meetings are supervised by a specialist palliative care professional; (3) groups use a palliative care register on which all identified patients are listed. Since the start in 2010, the number of PaTz-groups in the Netherlands has been growing consistently. Although the theory of all PaTz-groups is the same, the practical functioning of PaTz-groups may vary substantially, which may complicate further implementation of PaTz as well as interpretation of effect studies. This study aims to describe the variation in practice of PaTz-groups in the Netherlands.
In this prospective observational study, ten PaTz-groups logged and described the activities in their meetings as well as the registered and discussed patients and topics of discussions in registration forms for a 1 year follow-up period. In addition, non-participatory observations were performed in all participating groups. Meeting and patient characteristics were analysed using descriptive statistics. Conventional content analysis was performed in the analysis of topic discussions.
While the basic principles of PaTz are found in almost every PaTz-group, there is considerable variation in the practice and content of the meetings of different PaTz-groups. Most groups spend little time on other topics than their patients, although the number of patients discussed in a single meeting varies considerably, as well as the time spent on an individual patient. Most registered patients were diagnosed with cancer and patient discussions mainly concerned current affairs and rarely concerned future issues.
The basic principles are the cornerstone of any PaTz-group. At the same time, the observed variation between PaTz-groups indicates that tailoring a PaTz-group to the needs of its participants is important and may enhance its sustainability. The flexibility of PaTz-groups may also provide opportunity to modify the content and tools used, and improve identification of palliative patients and advance care planning.
PaTz(家庭姑息治疗)是一种在荷兰基层医疗环境中改善姑息治疗的方法。PaTz 有三个基本原则:(1)当地全科医生和临终关怀护士每年至少会面六次,以识别和讨论他们患有危及生命疾病的患者;(2)这些会议由一名专业姑息治疗专家监督;(3)小组使用姑息治疗登记册,所有识别出的患者都列在登记册上。自 2010 年开始,荷兰的 PaTz 小组数量一直在持续增长。尽管所有 PaTz 小组的理论都是相同的,但 PaTz 小组的实际运作方式可能会有很大差异,这可能会使 PaTz 的进一步实施以及效果研究的解释变得复杂。本研究旨在描述荷兰 PaTz 小组实践中的差异。
在这项前瞻性观察研究中,十个 PaTz 小组在为期 1 年的随访期间,使用登记表格记录并描述了会议中的活动,以及登记和讨论的患者以及讨论的主题。此外,对所有参与小组进行了非参与性观察。使用描述性统计分析了会议和患者特征。对主题讨论的分析采用常规内容分析。
虽然 PaTz 的基本原则几乎存在于每个 PaTz 小组中,但不同 PaTz 小组的会议实践和内容存在很大差异。大多数小组除了患者之外几乎没有时间讨论其他话题,尽管每次会议讨论的患者数量差异很大,以及花在单个患者身上的时间也不同。大多数登记的患者被诊断患有癌症,患者讨论主要涉及当前事务,很少涉及未来问题。
基本原则是任何 PaTz 小组的基石。同时,观察到的 PaTz 小组之间的差异表明,根据参与者的需求调整 PaTz 小组非常重要,并且可以提高其可持续性。PaTz 小组的灵活性也为修改使用的内容和工具提供了机会,并有助于识别姑息治疗患者和推进护理计划。