Legislative Yuan, Room 3309, No.1, Qingdao E. Rd., Zhongzheng Dist., Taipei, Taiwan.
Institute of Environmental and Occupational Health Sciences, National Taiwan University, Room 721, No. 17, Xu-Zhou Road, Zhongzheng District, Taipei, Taiwan.
Chemosphere. 2020 May;247:125692. doi: 10.1016/j.chemosphere.2019.125692. Epub 2019 Dec 17.
Multiple pesticide residues are frequently present in tea leaves and while the majority of residues satisfy Taiwan's current health regulations, there are potential health effects from pesticide exposure that are of great concern for tea drinkers. We undertook a systematic probabilistic risk assessment of 59 pesticides in tea leaves from 1629 tea leaf samples obtained by Taiwan's Food and Drug Administration in two monitoring surveys in 2015. Bayesian statistics used a Markov Chain Monte Carlo approach to estimate posterior distributions of pesticide residues in tea leaves, lifetime average daily doses and hazard quotients (HQs) of evaluated pesticides. We classified 95th percentile values of HQs into three categories: 0 < HQ < 0.5, 0.5 ≤ HQ ≤ 1 and 1 < HQ. The 95th percentiles of HQs for triazophos (3.39), carbofuran (2.04) and endosulfan (1.80) exceeded 1 in the adult population; the HQ for 3-OH carbofuran was 0.97 and was less than 0.5 for the remaining 55 pesticides. The health risk posed by pesticide residues for tea drinkers is negligible, if triazophos, carbofuran, endosulfan, and 3-OH carbofuran residues satisfy regulatory standards. However, five legacy pesticides, DDT, methomyl, carbofuran, dicofol and endosulfan, were identified. To reduce uncertainties, this study combined Bayesian statistics with a mode of action approach for systematic risk assessment of co-exposure to multiple pesticide residues in tea leaf samples. Measuring pesticide transfer rates will improve the quality of future risk assessments concerning residues in tea leaves. Appropriate management of pesticides in Taiwanese tea farms and monitoring of pesticide residues in imported tea is warranted to protect Taiwan's tea drinkers.
茶叶中经常存在多种农药残留,尽管大多数残留符合台湾现行的健康规定,但农药暴露仍存在潜在的健康影响,这引起了饮茶者的极大关注。我们对台湾食品药品监督管理局在 2015 年两次监测调查中从 1629 个茶叶样本中获得的 59 种农药进行了系统的概率风险评估。贝叶斯统计使用马尔可夫链蒙特卡罗方法来估计茶叶中农药残留的后验分布、终生平均日剂量和评估农药的危害指数(HQ)。我们将 HQ 的 95%百分位数分为三类:0<HQ<0.5、0.5≤HQ≤1 和 1<HQ。在成年人群中,三唑磷(3.39)、克百威(2.04)和硫丹(1.80)的 HQ95%百分位数超过 1;3-羟基克百威的 HQ 为 0.97,其余 55 种农药的 HQ 均小于 0.5。如果三唑磷、克百威、硫丹和 3-羟基克百威的残留符合监管标准,那么饮茶者因农药残留而面临的健康风险可以忽略不计。然而,仍有 5 种 legacy 农药(滴滴涕、灭多威、克百威、三氯杀螨醇和硫丹)被检出。为了降低不确定性,本研究将贝叶斯统计与作用模式方法相结合,对茶叶样本中多种农药残留的共暴露进行系统风险评估。测量农药转移率将提高未来关于茶叶中残留的风险评估的质量。台湾有必要对茶园中的农药进行适当管理,并对进口茶叶中的农药残留进行监测,以保护台湾的饮茶者。