Robinson Risa J, Hensel Edward C
Department of Mechanical Engineering, Rochester Institute of Technology, Rochester, NY, USA.
Inhal Toxicol. 2019 Nov-Dec;31(13-14):484-491. doi: 10.1080/08958378.2020.1718804. Epub 2020 Jan 29.
The extent to which electronic cigarette users will compensate for lower nicotine eliquids has implications on the risk associated with regulating eliquid composition. This article elucidates topography as a compensatory mechanism by investigating the impact of nicotine strength on total particulate matter (TPM) and nicotine consumed per puff. Thirty-three experienced vape pen users were assigned an NJOY™ VapePen and AVAIL™ brand Tobacco Row eliquid with their usual nicotine strength (L = 6 mg/mL, M = 12 mg/mL, H = 18 mg/mL) and vaped through RITs wPUM vape pen monitor to record every puff during 1 week. Nicotine and TPM yield per puff was determined accounting for the impact of topography characteristics on emissions and used to compute participant-specific mean yield per puff. Nicotine yields ranged from 0.01 to 0.05 mg/puff and varied widely within each group (L, M, and H nicotine strength). Group-wise mean flow rate was lower for L compared to M ( = 0.2) and duration was higher compared to M ( = 0.09). Larger TPM was consumed per puff for L compared to M ( = 0.07), yet nicotine per puff for L was less than M ( = 0.3). users took smaller volumes than L ( = 0.1) or M ( = 0.17), and there was little difference between L and M ( = 0.47). Evidence was provided for topography as a compensatory mechanism. Use of low nicotine strength eliquids can increase TPM, which can lead to increase in HPHC. Regulatory review of new products should consider natural use topography and realistic use exposures to nicotine, TPM and HPHCs.
电子烟使用者对尼古丁含量较低的电子烟液的补偿程度,对电子烟液成分监管所涉及的风险具有影响。本文通过研究尼古丁强度对每口吸入的总颗粒物(TPM)和消耗的尼古丁量的影响,阐明了抽吸行为作为一种补偿机制。33名有经验的电子烟笔使用者被分配使用NJOY™电子烟笔和AVAIL™品牌烟草味电子烟液,其尼古丁强度为他们常用的强度(低 = 6毫克/毫升,中 = 12毫克/毫升,高 = 18毫克/毫升),并通过RITs wPUM电子烟笔监测器进行抽吸,以记录1周内的每一口抽吸情况。考虑到抽吸行为特征对排放的影响,确定了每口的尼古丁和TPM产量,并用于计算参与者特定的每口平均产量。每口的尼古丁产量范围为0.01至0.05毫克/口,且在每个组(低、中、高尼古丁强度组)内差异很大。与中强度组相比,低强度组的组平均流速较低(P = 0.2),持续时间较长(P = 0.09)。与中强度组相比,低强度组每口消耗的TPM更大(P = 0.07),但每口的尼古丁含量低于中强度组(P = 0.3)。高尼古丁强度组使用者的抽吸量比低强度组(P = 0.1)或中强度组(P = 0.17)小,且低强度组和中强度组之间差异不大(P = 0.47)。有证据表明抽吸行为是一种补偿机制。使用低尼古丁强度的电子烟液会增加TPM,这可能导致有害和潜在有害成分增加。对新产品的监管审查应考虑自然使用的抽吸行为以及对尼古丁、TPM和有害及潜在有害成分的实际使用暴露情况。