Statistical Cybermetrics Research Group, University of Wolverhampton, Wulfruna Street, Wolverhampton WV1 1LY, UK.
FEMS Microbiol Lett. 2020 Jan 1;367(2). doi: 10.1093/femsle/fnaa021.
Immunology and microbiology research are essential for human and animal health. Unlike many other health fields, they do not usually centre around the curing or helping individual patients but focus on the microscopic scale instead. These fields are interesting from a gender perspective because two theories seeking to explain gender differences in career choices in the USA (people/things and communal/agentic goals) might produce conflicting expectations about their gender balances. This article assesses the gender shares of journal articles and gendered citation rates of five subfields of the Scopus Immunology and Microbiology broad category 1996-2014/18, for research with solely US author affiliations. Only Applied Microbiology and Biotechnology (38% female) had not reached gender parity in publishing by 2018. There was a female first author citation advantage in Parasitology but a disadvantage in Immunology. Immunology, Parasitology and Virology, had female last author citation disadvantages, but all gender effects were much smaller (<5%) than that of an extra author (10%-56%). Citation differences cannot therefore account for the current underrepresentation of women in senior roles.
免疫学和微生物学研究对于人类和动物的健康至关重要。与许多其他健康领域不同,它们通常不关注治疗或帮助个别患者,而是专注于微观层面。从性别角度来看,这些领域很有趣,因为有两个理论试图解释美国职业选择中的性别差异(人与物和公共与代理目标),这可能会对它们的性别平衡产生相互矛盾的期望。本文评估了 1996-2014/18 年间 Scopus 免疫学和微生物学大类别五个子领域的期刊文章的性别份额和有性别差异的引用率,这些研究仅与美国作者有关联。到 2018 年,只有应用微生物学和生物技术(38%为女性)在出版方面尚未实现性别均等。寄生虫学领域的第一作者引用有女性优势,但免疫学领域则相反。免疫学、寄生虫学和病毒学领域的最后作者引用存在女性劣势,但所有性别效应都比额外作者(10%-56%)的效应小得多(<5%)。因此,引用差异不能解释女性在高级职位中代表性不足的现状。