Fishman Michael, Williams Wadsworth A, Goodman Denise M, Ross Lainie Friedman
Pritzker School of Medicine, University of Chicago, Chicago, IL.
Department of Pediatrics, University of Chicago, Chicago, IL.
J Pediatr. 2017 Dec;191:244-249.e1. doi: 10.1016/j.jpeds.2017.08.044. Epub 2017 Oct 12.
To examine the gender of authors of original research in 3 high-impact pediatric journals between 2001 and 2016, given the importance of publishing on academic promotion, and to compare authorship gender with the percentage of women on editorial boards and with academic faculty composition.
We assessed the prevalence of female first and senior (last-listed) authorship of original research articles published in 3 pediatric-focused journals Pediatrics, JAMA Pediatrics (entitled Archives of Pediatric and Adolescent Medicine until 2013), and The Journal of Pediatrics. We also examined the gender breakdown of the main editors and the broader editorial boards of these journals. In addition, we examined whether junior female faculty co-authored with male or female senior faculty.
Of 3895 original articles, 22 were excluded because the gender of either the first or senior author could not be determined from the name. An analysis of authorship by year showed increasing female representation across the selected journals in both first (39.8% in 2001, 57.7% in 2016) and senior (28.6% in 2001, 38.1% in 2016) authors, respectively. Editorial boards also showed increasing female representation (17.8% in 2001 to 39.8% in 2016). Junior female faculty were more likely to co-author with senior female women (female first and last author); the gap remained unchanged despite the increasing number of women entering pediatrics.
Women are underrepresented as authors and editors, although the gap is closing. Junior women are less likely to co-author with senior men, which may be a disservice given current gender disparities in promotion and leadership.
鉴于发表论文对学术晋升的重要性,考察2001年至2016年间3种高影响力儿科期刊上原创研究的作者性别,并将作者性别与编辑委员会中女性所占百分比以及学术教员构成进行比较。
我们评估了发表在3种专注于儿科的期刊《儿科学》《美国医学会儿科学杂志》(2013年之前名为《儿科与青少年医学档案》)和《儿科学杂志》上的原创研究文章中女性第一作者和资深(最后列出)作者的比例。我们还研究了这些期刊主要编辑和更广泛编辑委员会的性别构成。此外,我们考察了初级女性教员与男性或女性资深教员共同署名的情况。
在3895篇原创文章中,有22篇被排除,因为无法从姓名中确定第一作者或资深作者的性别。按年份对作者情况进行的分析显示,在所选期刊中,第一作者(2001年为39.8%,2016年为57.7%)和资深作者(2001年为28.6%,2016年为38.1%)中女性的比例均在增加。编辑委员会中女性的比例也在增加(从2001年的17.8%增至2016年的39.8%)。初级女性教员更有可能与资深女性共同署名(女性为第一作者和最后作者);尽管进入儿科领域的女性数量不断增加,但这一差距仍未改变。
女性作为作者和编辑的代表性不足,尽管差距正在缩小。初级女性与资深男性共同署名的可能性较小,鉴于目前晋升和领导方面的性别差异,这可能不利。