School of Health & Social Care, Sighthill Campus, Edinburgh Napier University, EH11 4BN, United Kingdom.
School of Health & Social Care, Sighthill Campus, Edinburgh Napier University, EH11 4BN, United Kingdom.
Women Birth. 2021 Feb;34(1):77-86. doi: 10.1016/j.wombi.2020.01.007. Epub 2020 Feb 3.
In several countries, midwifery students undertake continuity of care experiences as part of their pre-registration education. This is thought to enable the development of a woman-centred approach, as well as providing students with the skills to work in continuity models. A comprehensive overview of factors that may promote optimal learning within continuity experiences is lacking.
To identify barriers and facilitators to optimal learning within continuity experiences, in order to provide a holistic overview of factors that may impact on, modify and determine learning within this educational model.
An integrative literature review was undertaken using a five-step framework which established the search strategy, screening and eligibility assessment, and data evaluation processes. Quality of included literature was critically appraised and extracted data were analysed thematically.
Three key themes were identified. A central theme was relationships, which are instrumental in learning within continuity experiences. Conflict or coherence represents the different models of care in which the continuity experience is situated, which may conflict with or cohere to the intentions of this educational model. The final theme is setting the standards, which emerged from the lack of evidence and guidance to inform the implementation of student placements within continuity experiences.
The learning from continuity experiences must be optimised to prepare students to be confident, competent and enthusiastic to work in continuity models, ultimately at the point of graduation. This will require an evidence-based approach to inform clear guidance around the intent, implementation, documentation and assessment of continuity experiences.
在一些国家,助产士学生在注册前的教育中会进行连续性护理体验,这被认为可以培养以女性为中心的方法,并为学生提供在连续性模式下工作的技能。缺乏对连续性体验中促进最佳学习的因素的全面概述。
确定连续性体验中最佳学习的障碍和促进因素,以便全面了解可能影响、改变和决定该教育模式中学习的因素。
采用五步框架进行综合文献回顾,确定搜索策略、筛选和资格评估以及数据评估过程。批判性地评估纳入文献的质量,并对提取的数据进行主题分析。
确定了三个关键主题。一个核心主题是关系,它对连续性体验中的学习至关重要。冲突或一致性代表了连续性体验所处的不同护理模式,这些模式可能与该教育模式的意图冲突或一致。最后一个主题是设定标准,这是由于缺乏证据和指导来为连续性体验中的学生安置提供信息而产生的。
必须优化连续性体验中的学习,以培养学生在连续性模式中充满信心、能力和热情地工作,最终在毕业时。这将需要一种基于证据的方法,为连续性体验的意图、实施、记录和评估提供明确的指导。