Inland Norway University of Applied Sciences, Lillehammer, Norway.
Norwegian Olympic Sport Center, Oslo, Norway.
Scand J Med Sci Sports. 2020 May;30(5):865-877. doi: 10.1111/sms.13634. Epub 2020 Feb 20.
In this study, we compare the effects of isocaloric high- (HIGH: 2 g kg d , n = 19) and low-protein diet (LOW: 1 g kg d , n = 19) on changes in body composition, muscle strength, and endocrine variables in response to a 10-day military field exercise with energy deficit, followed by 7 days of recovery. Body composition (DXA), one repetition maximum (1RM) bench and leg press, counter-movement jump height (CMJ) and blood variables were assessed before and after the exercise. Performance and blood variables were reassessed after 7 days of recovery. The 10-day exercise resulted in severe energy deficit in both LOW and HIGH (-4373 ± 1250, -4271 ± 1075 kcal d ) and led to decreased body mass (-6.1%, -5.2%), fat mass (-40.5%, -33.4%), 1RM bench press (-9.5%, -9.7%), 1RM leg press (-7.8%, -8.3%), and CMJ (-14.7%, -14.6%), with no differences between groups. No change was seen for fat-free mass. In both groups, the exercise led to a switch toward a catabolic physiological milieu, evident as reduced levels of anabolic hormones (testosterone, IGF-1) and increased levels of cortisol (more pronounced in HIGH, P < .05). Both groups also displayed substantial increases in creatine kinase. After 7 days of recovery, most variables had returned to close-to pre-exercise levels, except for CMJ, which remained at reduced levels. In conclusion, increased protein intake during 10-day military field exercise with severe energy deficiency did not mitigate loss of body mass or impairment of physical performance.
在这项研究中,我们比较了等热量高蛋白(HIGH:2g/kg/d,n=19)和低蛋白饮食(LOW:1g/kg/d,n=19)对 10 天军事野外训练和能量不足后身体成分、肌肉力量和内分泌变量的影响,随后进行了 7 天的恢复。在训练前后评估了身体成分(DXA)、1 次重复最大(1RM)卧推和腿推、反跳高度(CMJ)和血液变量。在 7 天的恢复后再次评估了表现和血液变量。10 天的训练导致 LOW 和 HIGH 两组均出现严重的能量不足(-4373±1250,-4271±1075 千卡/d),导致体重下降(-6.1%,-5.2%),体脂减少(-40.5%,-33.4%),1RM 卧推减少(-9.5%,-9.7%),1RM 腿推减少(-7.8%,-8.3%),CMJ 减少(-14.7%,-14.6%),但两组之间无差异。无脂体重无变化。两组在训练后都出现了向分解代谢生理环境的转变,表现为合成代谢激素(睾丸酮、IGF-1)水平降低和皮质醇水平升高(HIGH 组更为明显,P<.05)。两组的肌酸激酶也显著升高。7 天恢复后,大多数变量已接近恢复到训练前水平,除了 CMJ 仍处于较低水平。结论是,在严重能量不足的 10 天军事野外训练中增加蛋白质摄入并没有减轻体重损失或身体表现受损。