Institute of Diagnostic and Interventional Radiology, University Hospital Zurich, Switzerland; University of Zurich, Faculty of Medicine, Switzerland.
Institute of Diagnostic and Interventional Radiology, University Hospital Zurich, Switzerland; University of Zurich, Faculty of Medicine, Switzerland.
Acad Radiol. 2021 Jul;28(7):988-994. doi: 10.1016/j.acra.2020.01.014. Epub 2020 Feb 6.
To assess if vessel suppression (VS) improves nodule detection rate, interreader agreement, and reduces reading time in oncologic chest computed tomography (CT).
One-hundred consecutive oncologic patients (65 male; median age 60y) who underwent contrast-enhanced chest CT were retrospectively included. For all exams, additional VS series (ClearRead CT, Riverrain Technologies, Miamisburg) were reconstructed. Two groups of three radiologists each with matched experience were defined. Each group evaluated the SD-CT as well as VS-CT. Each reader marked the presence, size, and position of pulmonary nodules and documented reading time. In addition, for the VS-CT the presence of false positive nodules had to be stated. Cohen's Kappa (k) was used to calculate the interreader-agreement between groups. Reading time was compared using paired t test.
Nodule detection rate was significantly higher in VS-CT compared to the SD-CT (+21%; p <0.001). Interreader-agreement was higher in the VS-CT (k = 0.431, moderate agreement) compared to SD-CT (k = 0.209, fair agreement). Almost all VS-CT series had false positive findings (97-99 out of 100). Average reading time was significantly shorter in the VS-CT compared to the SD-CT (154 ± 134vs. 194 ± 126; 21%, p<0.001).
Vessel suppression increases nodule detection rate, improves interreader agreement, and reduces reading time in chest CT of oncologic patients. Due to false positive results a consensus reading with the SD-CT is essential.
评估血管抑制(VS)是否能提高肿瘤性胸部 CT 中的结节检出率、改善读者间的一致性,并减少阅读时间。
回顾性纳入 100 例连续的肿瘤患者(65 例男性;中位年龄 60 岁),均行增强胸部 CT 检查。所有检查均重建了附加的 VS 序列(ClearRead CT,Riverrain Technologies,Miamisburg)。定义了两组各 3 名经验匹配的放射科医生。每组医生均评估了标准 CT(SD-CT)和 VS-CT。每位读者标记了肺结节的存在、大小和位置,并记录了阅读时间。此外,还需要对 VS-CT 中的假阳性结节进行标注。使用 Cohen's Kappa(k)计算组间的读者间一致性。使用配对 t 检验比较阅读时间。
VS-CT 比 SD-CT 的结节检出率显著提高(+21%;p<0.001)。VS-CT 的读者间一致性高于 SD-CT(k=0.431,中度一致性)。几乎所有 VS-CT 系列都有假阳性结果(100 个中有 97-99 个)。VS-CT 的平均阅读时间明显短于 SD-CT(154±134 比 194±126;21%,p<0.001)。
血管抑制可提高肿瘤性胸部 CT 中的结节检出率、改善读者间的一致性,并减少阅读时间。由于存在假阳性结果,因此需要与 SD-CT 进行共识阅读。