Department of Radiation Oncology, University Medical Center Mannheim, Medical Faculty Mannheim, Heidelberg University, Germany.
Medical Faculty Mannheim, Heidelberg University, Germany.
Radiother Oncol. 2020 Nov;152:208-215. doi: 10.1016/j.radonc.2020.01.006. Epub 2020 Feb 7.
No evidence has been presented until now whether recommendations given in recently issued guidelines concerning CIED-bearing patients significantly decrease RT-related complications.
160 RT-cases were prospectively treated with 3D-CRT, IMRT, SBRT using exclusively 6 MV photons (n = 146) and electrons (n = 14) according to the 2015 issued German DEGRO/DGK-guideline for CIED-bearing patients and compared to 40 RT-cases (3D-CRT, 10-23 MV photons (n = 39) and electrons (n = 1)) of CIED-bearing patients which were treated in concordance to the 1994 issued AAPM-guideline.
With AAPM-recommendations, complications occurred in 7/39 (17.95%) photon-RT cases, one patient experienced inadequate defibrillation therapy. For all patients treated with photon energies between 6 and 23 MV, a relative risk for CIED failure if treated with > 6 MV was calculated to be 9.03 (95% CI 5.24-15.55). After implementation of the DEGRO/DGK guideline, no complications were noted in 147 cases treated with photons, even though CIED-doses were as high as 5.37 Gy. In 13 cases treated with electrons, one PM lost patient-related data in a patient receiving antiproliferative RT to mammary glands.
Implementation of the German DEGRO/DGK-guideline effectively prevented radiation-associated CIED failures in patients treated with photons. Limitation of photon energy to 6 MV, suspension of defibrillation therapy in ICDs, surveillance of patients according to risk stratification and avoidance of direct irradiation of CIEDs should become standard of care.
目前尚无证据表明,最近发布的有关植入式心脏电子设备(CIED)患者的指南中的建议是否能显著降低放射治疗(RT)相关并发症。
160 例 RT 病例前瞻性地接受了 3D-CRT、调强放疗(IMRT)和立体定向放疗(SBRT),这些治疗均使用 6MV 光子(n=146)和电子(n=14),完全符合 2015 年发布的德国 DEGRO/DGK 指南针对 CIED 患者的建议,并与 40 例 CIED 患者(3D-CRT,10-23MV 光子(n=39)和电子(n=1))的 RT 病例进行了比较,这些病例的治疗是根据 1994 年发布的 AAPM 指南进行的。
根据 AAPM 指南的建议,在 39 例光子 RT 病例中,有 7 例(17.95%)出现并发症,1 例患者出现了不充分的除颤治疗。对于所有接受 6-23MV 光子能量治疗的患者,计算出如果接受>6MV 光子能量治疗,CIED 故障的相对风险为 9.03(95%CI 5.24-15.55)。在实施 DEGRO/DGK 指南后,在接受光子治疗的 147 例患者中,没有出现并发症,尽管 CIED 剂量高达 5.37Gy。在接受电子治疗的 13 例患者中,有 1 例 PM 丢失了接受乳腺抗增殖 RT 治疗的患者相关数据。
德国 DEGRO/DGK 指南的实施有效地防止了接受光子治疗的患者发生与放射相关的 CIED 故障。将光子能量限制在 6MV,暂停 ICD 中的除颤治疗,根据风险分层对患者进行监测,并避免直接照射 CIED,应成为标准治疗方法。