Department of oral and maxillofacial radiology, Stomatological Hospital, Peking University, Beijing, China.
Dentomaxillofac Radiol. 2020 Jul;49(5):20190336. doi: 10.1259/dmfr.20190336. Epub 2020 Feb 26.
The purpose of this study was to investigate the image quality of cone beam CT (CBCT) under different exposure parameters and the relationship between contrast-to-noise and visibility of eight anatomical structures.
CBCT images for the evaluation of subjective image quality were acquired on an anthropopathic phantom containing a human skeleton embedded in soft tissue equivalent materials using 25 exposure protocols. Visibility of eight anatomical structures was evaluated by five independent observers. Using the SEDENTEXCT IQ Image Quality phantom, the contrast-to-noise ratio (CNR) was calculated by ImageJ software.
A reduction on the visibility of anatomical structures was seen under lower exposure parameters. However, for 84% of the protocols, visibility of anatomical structures remained acceptable even under some lower parameter settings. As CNR increased, the visibility of anatomical structures also increased correspondingly. A change point could be found in the CNR interval 29.42-36.51 after which the visibility of anatomical structures no longer increases with the increase of CNR.
Although CNR decrease under a lower exposure parameter, the image quality often remained acceptable at exposure levels below the manufacture's recommended settings. It is possible to standardize subjective image quality by physical factors. Currently, it is not possible to predetermine a change point CNR value due to different CBCT machine and variation of diagnostic tasks.
本研究旨在探讨不同曝光参数下锥形束 CT(CBCT)的图像质量,以及 8 种解剖结构的对比噪声比(CNR)与可视性之间的关系。
使用 25 种曝光方案,在包含嵌入软组织等效材料中的人体骨骼的拟人化体模上获取用于评估主观图像质量的 CBCT 图像。由 5 名独立观察者评估 8 种解剖结构的可视性。使用 SEDENTEXCT IQ 图像质量体模,通过 ImageJ 软件计算 CNR。
在较低的曝光参数下,解剖结构的可视性降低。然而,在 84%的方案中,即使在某些较低的参数设置下,解剖结构的可视性仍然可以接受。随着 CNR 的增加,解剖结构的可视性也相应增加。在 CNR 间隔 29.42-36.51 后,可以发现一个转折点,此后解剖结构的可视性不再随着 CNR 的增加而增加。
尽管在较低的曝光参数下 CNR 降低,但在低于制造商推荐设置的曝光水平下,图像质量通常仍然可以接受。可以通过物理因素来标准化主观图像质量。目前,由于不同的 CBCT 机器和诊断任务的变化,无法预先确定 CNR 值的转折点。