Department of Health Policy, Management & Leadership, School of Public Health, West Virginia University, Morgantown, West Virginia, United States of America.
Department of Geology & Environmental Sciences, State University of New York at Fredonia, Fredonia, New York, United States of America.
PLoS One. 2020 Feb 11;15(2):e0228640. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0228640. eCollection 2020.
Medical practitioners, trained to isolate health within and upon the body of the individual, are now challenged to negotiate research and population health theories that link health status to geographic location as evidence suggests a connection between place and health. This paper builds an integrated place-health model and structural competency analytical framework with nine domains and four levels of proficiency that is utilized to assess a community-based photovoice project's ability to shift the practice of medicine by medical students from the surface of the body to the body within a place. Analysis of the medical student's photovoice data demonstrated that the students achieved structural competency level 1 proficiency and came to understand how health might be connected to place represented by six of the nine domains of the structural competency framework. Results suggest that medical student's engagement with place-health systemic, institutional and structural forces deepens when they co-create narratives of their lived experiences in a place with patients as community members during a community-based photovoice project. Given the importance of place-health theories to explain population health outcomes, a place-health model and structural competency analytical framework utilized during a community-based photovoice project could help medical students merge the image of patients as singular bodies into bodies set within a context.
医学从业者接受的培训是将健康孤立在个体的身体内部和外部,现在他们面临着挑战,需要研究和人口健康理论,这些理论将健康状况与地理位置联系起来,因为有证据表明,地点和健康之间存在联系。本文构建了一个综合的地点-健康模型和结构能力分析框架,包括九个领域和四个熟练程度级别,用于评估基于社区的影像声音项目是否有能力通过医学生将医学实践从身体表面转移到特定地点的身体内部。对医学生的影像声音数据进行分析表明,学生达到了结构能力水平 1 的熟练程度,并开始理解健康如何与结构能力框架的九个领域中的六个领域所代表的地点联系起来。结果表明,当医学生在基于社区的影像声音项目中与患者作为社区成员共同创作他们在特定地点的生活经历的叙述时,他们对地点-健康系统、机构和结构力量的参与会加深。鉴于地点-健康理论对于解释人口健康结果的重要性,在基于社区的影像声音项目中使用地点-健康模型和结构能力分析框架可以帮助医学生将患者作为单一身体的形象融入到特定背景下的身体中。