Faculty of Nutrition, Federal University of Alagoas (UFAL), Campus A.C. Simões, BR 104 Norte, Tabuleiro do Martins, 57072-970, Maceió, Alagoas, Brazil.
Postgraduate Program in Health Sciences, Institute of Biological and Health Sciences/UFAL, Maceió, Alagoas, Brasil.
BMC Pediatr. 2020 Feb 11;20(1):65. doi: 10.1186/s12887-020-1940-6.
The methodology currently used for nutritional assessment of populations classifies children according to four conditions: eutrophy, wasting, stunting, and overweight. However, children can be stunted and wasted concomitantly. Similarly, they can be stunted and overweight. These conditions are associated with greater susceptibility to mortality or chronic diseases, respectively. This work presents an adaptation of Waterlow's classification (AWC), which discriminates six nutritional conditions. Additionally, it provides a command routine in Stata, which processes the z-scores of the anthropometric indices height-for-age and weight-for-height and presents the respective prevalence of the nutritional conditions.
Data from two household surveys were used to demonstrate the application of AWC, which were conducted in 1992 (n = 1229) and 2015 (n = 987), with probabilistic samples of children (< 5 years) in Alagoas, Northeast Brazil. AWC is based on a cross-classification scheme, involving the categories obtained with height-for-age (z < - 2; z ≥ - 2) and weight-for-height (z < - 2; - 2 to 2; z > 2).
The prevalence obtained with AWC in 1992 and 2015 was, respectively: eutrophy (71.0/80.2), stunting (20.8/2.7), wasting (0.8/2.1), concurrent stunting and wasting (0.5/0.0), overweight (4.8/14.4) and short stature with overweight (2.0/0.5). The prevalence of wasting, concurrent wasting and stunting, and for short stature with overweight was never higher than 2.3%. Possibly these values should be much higher in countries where there is a high prevalence of undernutrition. In total, 472 children had low height-for-age. By the usual anthropometric classification, they would be classified as chronic undernourished. However, 39 (8.3%) of them were also overweight and seven (1.5%) had concurrent stunting and wasting, a condition at extreme risk of mortality, which is perhaps the explanation for its low prevalence in cross-sectional studies.
In addition to identifying wasted, stunted and overweight children, AWC also identified children with two other conditions, which are generally neglected in most nutritional surveys. Each of these nutritional conditions have different characteristics (aetiology, preventive, and therapeutic approach, damage to the patient's health, and priority level in public policy). Such aspects justify their identification in the distinct scenarios where nutritional surveys are developed.
目前用于人群营养评估的方法学根据四种情况对儿童进行分类:营养良好、消瘦、发育迟缓、超重。然而,儿童可能同时存在消瘦和发育迟缓,也可能同时存在消瘦和超重。这些情况分别与更高的死亡率或慢性病易感性相关。本研究介绍了 Waterlow 分类法(AWC)的改编版,该分类法可区分六种营养状况。此外,它还提供了一个 Stata 命令程序,可处理身高别年龄和体重别身高的人体测量指数 z 分数,并呈现相应的营养状况流行率。
使用来自两次家庭调查的数据来演示 AWC 的应用,这两次调查分别于 1992 年(n=1229)和 2015 年(n=987)进行,采用巴西东北部阿拉戈斯州儿童(<5 岁)的概率抽样。AWC 基于交叉分类方案,涉及身高别年龄(z<−2;z≥−2)和体重别身高(z<−2;−2 至 2;z>2)获得的类别。
1992 年和 2015 年 AWC 的流行率分别为:营养良好(71.0/80.2)、发育迟缓(20.8/2.7)、消瘦(0.8/2.1)、消瘦和发育迟缓同时存在(0.5/0.0)、超重(4.8/14.4)和超重合并矮小(2.0/0.5)。消瘦、消瘦和发育迟缓同时存在以及超重合并矮小的流行率从未超过 2.3%。在营养不足流行率较高的国家,这些数值可能会更高。共有 472 名儿童身高别年龄较低。按照常规人体测量学分类,他们将被归类为慢性营养不良。然而,其中 39 名(8.3%)儿童同时超重,7 名(1.5%)同时存在消瘦和发育迟缓,这种情况处于死亡的极高风险中,这也许可以解释其在横断面研究中低流行率的原因。
AWC 除了识别消瘦、发育迟缓和超重儿童外,还识别出了另外两种通常在大多数营养调查中被忽视的儿童营养状况。这些营养状况中的每一种都具有不同的特征(病因、预防和治疗方法、对患者健康的损害以及公共政策中的优先级别)。这些方面证明了在开展营养调查的不同情况下识别这些状况的合理性。