Appel Jacob M
Icahn School of Medicine at Mount Sinai, Mount Sinai Hospital, Mount Sinai St. Luke's-West Hospital, Mount Sinai Beth Israel Hospital, New York, NY.
Focus (Am Psychiatr Publ). 2019 Oct;17(4):360-364. doi: 10.1176/appi.focus.20190021. Epub 2019 Nov 6.
Confidentiality has long been a core value in medical ethics, but the parameters of this value have rapidly evolved. The principle is now best understood in the context of competing loyalties: Physicians owe patients a broad duty to protect confidences, but that duty is limited-in specific circumstances-by a competing obligation to protect the health of others and the general public welfare. The trend is increasingly toward more disclosure. The author examines three areas in which rules governing confidentiality have rapidly evolved in recent decades-the development of a duty to warn or protect potential third-party victims in the wake of the seminal California case of the establishment of a psychotherapist-patient privilege for the federal courts in and the codification of protections for health information under HIPAA-and how these rules have been implemented. The author also notes the complexities of protecting patient confidentiality in the context of evolving Internet technologies.
保密长期以来一直是医学伦理的核心价值,但这一价值的范围已迅速演变。现在,在相互冲突的忠诚关系背景下,对这一原则的理解最为恰当:医生对患者负有广泛的保密责任,但在特定情况下,这一责任会因保护他人健康和公众福利的相互冲突的义务而受到限制。越来越多的趋势是披露更多信息。作者审视了近几十年来保密规则迅速演变的三个领域——在具有开创性的加利福尼亚案件之后出现的警告或保护潜在第三方受害者的义务的发展、2006年为联邦法院确立心理治疗师 - 患者特权以及根据《健康保险流通与责任法案》(HIPAA)对健康信息保护进行编纂——以及这些规则是如何实施的。作者还指出了在不断发展的互联网技术背景下保护患者保密信息的复杂性。