From the Department of Radiology, Eulji University College of Medicine, Eulji University Hospital, Daejeon.
Departments of Radiology.
Invest Radiol. 2020 Jun;55(6):387-395. doi: 10.1097/RLI.0000000000000651.
The aim of this study was to conduct a radiopathologic evaluation of right-angled traction bronchiectasis to differentiate idiopathic pulmonary fibrosis (IPF) without honeycombing from idiopathic nonspecific interstitial pneumonia (NSIP).
The derivation cohort included 78 consecutive patients with idiopathic NSIP (n = 39) or IPF (n = 39) without honeycombing who underwent preoperative thin-section computed tomography scans at a single tertiary hospital. The validation cohort comprised 22 patients (14 IPF and 8 NSIP) from another institution. We assessed conventional computed tomography findings, right-angled traction bronchiectasis on minimum intensity projection (MinIP) images, and pathologic features associated with right-angled bronchiectasis. Right-angled traction bronchiectasis was defined as abrupt kinking of a single bronchus by over 90 degrees or an abrupt angle close to 180 degrees of branching bronchi in the background of fibrosis. In the validation cohort, we evaluated the proportion of correct IPF diagnoses and interobserver agreement of 4 radiologists before and after reviewing MinIP images.
A probable usual interstitial pneumonia (UIP) pattern (odds ratio [OR], 6.948; 95% confidence interval [CI], 1.525-31.654; P = 0.012) and right-angled traction bronchiectasis (OR, 6.004; 95% CI, 1.980-18.209; P = 0.002) were independently associated with IPF. Patients with right-angled traction bronchiectasis were more likely to have extensive reticular opacity (OR, 1.149; 95% CI, 1.077-1.225; P < 0.001) and pathologically were more likely to have a broad extent of subpleural fibrosis (OR, 4.000; 95% CI, 1.457-10.987; P = 0.007) and relatively thick fibrosis (OR, 7.750; 95% CI, 2.504-23.991; P < 0.001). After reviewing MinIP images, the proportion of correct diagnoses increased from 40.9% to 54.5% to 50.0% to 77.3%. The mean kappa value for right-angled traction bronchiectasis was 0.489 ± 0.192.
Right-angled traction bronchiectasis pathologically reflected a subpleural predominance of fibrosis and partly supported the radiologic differentiation of IPF without honeycombing from idiopathic NSIP.
本研究旨在对直角牵引性支气管扩张进行放射病理学评估,以区分无蜂窝状改变的特发性肺纤维化(IPF)与特发性非特异性间质性肺炎(NSIP)。
本研究的推导队列纳入了在一家三级医院接受术前薄层 CT 扫描的 78 例连续特发性 NSIP 患者(n=39)或无蜂窝状改变的 IPF 患者(n=39)。验证队列由来自另一家机构的 22 例患者(14 例 IPF 和 8 例 NSIP)组成。我们评估了常规 CT 表现、最小强度投影(MinIP)图像上的直角牵引性支气管扩张以及与直角支气管扩张相关的病理特征。直角牵引性支气管扩张定义为单个支气管的突然扭曲超过 90 度,或背景纤维化中分支支气管的突然接近 180 度的角。在验证队列中,我们在查看 MinIP 图像前后评估了 4 名放射科医生对 IPF 诊断的正确率和观察者间一致性。
可能的普通间质性肺炎(UIP)模式(比值比[OR],6.948;95%置信区间[CI],1.525-31.654;P=0.012)和直角牵引性支气管扩张(OR,6.004;95%CI,1.980-18.209;P=0.002)与 IPF 独立相关。存在直角牵引性支气管扩张的患者更有可能出现广泛的网状混浊(OR,1.149;95%CI,1.077-1.225;P<0.001),且病理上更有可能出现广泛的胸膜下纤维化(OR,4.000;95%CI,1.457-10.987;P=0.007)和相对较厚的纤维化(OR,7.750;95%CI,2.504-23.991;P<0.001)。查看 MinIP 图像后,正确诊断的比例从 40.9%增加到 54.5%,再增加到 50.0%,最后增加到 77.3%。直角牵引性支气管扩张的平均 Kappa 值为 0.489±0.192。
直角牵引性支气管扩张在病理上反映了胸膜下纤维化的优势,部分支持了无蜂窝状改变的 IPF 与特发性 NSIP 的放射学鉴别。