Chen P L, Hong J B, Shen L J, Chen Y T, Wang S J, Liao Y H
Graduate Institute of Medical Genomics and Proteomics, Taipei, Taiwan.
Department of Medical Genetics, National Taiwan University Hospital, Taipei, Taiwan.
Br J Dermatol. 2020 Oct;183(4):655-663. doi: 10.1111/bjd.18949. Epub 2020 Mar 18.
The efficacy of topical rapamycin is well documented for tuberous sclerosis complex (TSC)-related facial angiofibromas (FAs). Calcitriol has been shown to lessen skin fibrosis and may be therapeutically beneficial to FAs.
To evaluate whether topical rapamycin-calcitriol combination is an effective and safe treatment for TSC-related FAs.
Fifty-two patients with TSC with FAs were enrolled in this prospective study including three 12-week periods. In period 1, either topical rapamycin 0·1% or calcitriol 0·0003% single-agent therapy vs. their combination was applied in a double-blind, left-right-randomized, split-face comparison. The primary outcome was the reduction of modified Facial Angiofibroma Severity Index (mFASI) at week 12. In period 2, the patients were reassigned to use on both cheeks the ointment that resulted in the better primary outcome in period 1. The treatment was discontinued in period 3 (week 25-36) and a follow-up mFASI was scored to evaluate the degree of recurrence.
The mean changes in mFASI at week 12 compared with baseline were -0·92, -0·44 and -1·09 for rapamycin (P ≤ 0·001), calcitriol (P = 0·039) and rapamycin-calcitriol combination (P ≤ 0·001), respectively. Although rapamycin-calcitriol combination and rapamycin had similar statistically significant decreases of mFASI at week 12, rapamycin-calcitriol combination resulted in faster improvement in erythema, greater reduction of papule elevation and longer durability after discontinuing treatment than rapamycin alone. The treatments were well tolerated.
This randomized clinical trial demonstrates that topical rapamycin-calcitriol combination therapy is an effective and safe regimen for TSC-related FAs. What is already known about this topic? Facial angiofibromas (FAs) cause substantial psychological distress in individuals with tuberous sclerosis complex (TSC), but invasive procedural treatments are not applicable to all patients. Topical rapamycin has been demonstrated as an effective and safe treatment regimen for TSC-related FAs. What does this study add? Compared with baseline (day 0), both topical rapamycin 0·1% and rapamycin 0·1%-calcitriol 0·0003% combination ointment achieved statistically significant reductions in modified Facial Angiofibroma Severity Index at week 12. Compared with rapamycin alone, extended use of the rapamycin-calcitriol combination regimen until week 24 showed more effectiveness in decreasing papule elevation and could maintain a longer therapeutic effect after treatment discontinuation. Linked Comment: Lee. Br J Dermatol 2020; 183:604-606.
外用雷帕霉素治疗结节性硬化症(TSC)相关面部血管纤维瘤(FA)的疗效已有充分记录。已证明骨化三醇可减轻皮肤纤维化,可能对FA具有治疗益处。
评估外用雷帕霉素 - 骨化三醇联合治疗对TSC相关FA是否有效且安全。
52例患有FA的TSC患者纳入了这项前瞻性研究,包括三个12周的阶段。在第1阶段,采用双盲、左右随机、半脸对照的方式,应用0.1%外用雷帕霉素或0.0003%骨化三醇单药治疗及其联合治疗。主要结局是第12周时改良面部血管纤维瘤严重程度指数(mFASI)的降低。在第2阶段,患者重新分配使用在第1阶段导致更好主要结局的软膏涂于双颊。在第3阶段(第25 - 36周)停止治疗,并对mFASI进行随访评分以评估复发程度。
与基线相比,第12周时雷帕霉素组(P≤0.001)、骨化三醇组(P = 0.039)和雷帕霉素 - 骨化三醇联合组(P≤0.001)的mFASI平均变化分别为 - 0.92、 - 0.44和 - 1.09。尽管雷帕霉素 - 骨化三醇联合组和雷帕霉素组在第12周时mFASI的降低在统计学上具有相似的显著性,但雷帕霉素 - 骨化三醇联合组在红斑改善方面更快,丘疹隆起的降低幅度更大,且停药后的疗效持续时间比单独使用雷帕霉素更长。这些治疗耐受性良好。
这项随机临床试验表明,外用雷帕霉素 - 骨化三醇联合治疗是一种治疗TSC相关FA的有效且安全的方案。关于该主题已知的信息有哪些?面部血管纤维瘤(FA)给结节性硬化症(TSC)患者带来了严重的心理困扰,但侵入性手术治疗并不适用于所有患者。外用雷帕霉素已被证明是一种治疗TSC相关FA的有效且安全的治疗方案。本研究增加了什么内容?与基线(第0天)相比,0.1%外用雷帕霉素和0.1%雷帕霉素 - 0.0003%骨化三醇联合软膏在第12周时改良面部血管纤维瘤严重程度指数均有统计学显著降低。与单独使用雷帕霉素相比,将雷帕霉素 - 骨化三醇联合方案延长至第24周显示在降低丘疹隆起方面更有效,且停药后能维持更长的治疗效果。相关评论:Lee。《英国皮肤病学杂志》2020年;183:604 - 606。