University of Portsmouth, UK.
Portsmouth City Council, UK.
J Interpers Violence. 2022 Apr;37(7-8):NP5367-NP5393. doi: 10.1177/0886260520907356. Epub 2020 Feb 17.
There has been increased interest in the subjective experiences of participants of community partner abuse intervention programs (PAIPs). In the context of high attrition rates, qualitative research is needed to understand the factors associated with sustained engagement and dropout. Using a community nonmandated PAIP, the current study is a rare investigation of the experiences of both completers and noncompleters. We explored the differences between completers' and noncompleters' perceptions of the treatment process, the reasons for sustained program engagement, and the perceived outcomes of treatment. Semi-structured interviews were completed with 14 participants: nine completers and five noncompleters. The majority of participants were referred by children's social care and were unemployed at the time of interview. The interviews were conducted by research staff independent from the treatment-providing organization. Three themes emerged from the data: (a) Treatment as Challenging Yet Enlightening, (b) the Importance of a Well-timed and Safe Therapeutic Environment, and (c) Improved Emotional Self-Management Due to Treatment. Results highlighted how structured individualized sessions, underpinned by a strong therapeutic alliance with facilitators, helped participants increase their interpersonal problem-solving and communication skills. The study reinforced the importance of developing a therapeutic alliance and providing structured individualized treatment characterized by flexibility and accessibility. Noncompletion was perceived as related to known risk factors and treatment readiness. Therefore, it may be beneficial to employ screening measures to monitor these factors. Future research should use larger, more diverse samples to further investigate subjective experiences of PAIP completers and, particularly, noncompleters to enhance the limited literature in this area.
人们对参与社区伙伴虐待干预计划(PAIP)的参与者的主观体验越来越感兴趣。在高流失率的背景下,需要进行定性研究,以了解与持续参与和辍学相关的因素。本研究使用社区非强制性 PAIP,是对完成者和未完成者的经验进行罕见调查。我们探讨了完成者和未完成者对治疗过程的看法、持续参与计划的原因以及治疗效果的差异。对 14 名参与者进行了半结构化访谈:9 名完成者和 5 名未完成者。大多数参与者是由儿童社会照顾机构转介的,在接受采访时没有工作。采访由独立于治疗机构的研究人员进行。数据中出现了三个主题:(a)治疗既具有挑战性又具有启发性,(b)及时和安全的治疗环境的重要性,以及(c)治疗后情绪自我管理的改善。结果强调了结构化的个性化治疗的重要性,这些治疗以与治疗师建立牢固的治疗联盟为基础,帮助参与者提高了他们的人际交往问题解决和沟通技巧。研究强调了建立治疗联盟的重要性,并提供了以灵活性和可及性为特点的结构化个性化治疗。未完成被认为与已知的风险因素和治疗准备有关。因此,采用筛选措施来监测这些因素可能会有所帮助。未来的研究应使用更大、更多样化的样本,进一步调查 PAIP 完成者的主观体验,特别是未完成者的体验,以丰富该领域有限的文献。