Sturgess Danielle, Woodhams Jessica, Tonkin Matthew
1 University of Birmingham, UK.
2 Birmingham City University, UK.
Int J Offender Ther Comp Criminol. 2016 Dec;60(16):1873-1896. doi: 10.1177/0306624X15586038. Epub 2016 Jul 28.
A systematic review of the reasons why detained adult offenders fail to attend or successfully complete treatment programme(s) was conducted. An initial search of the literature identified 2,827 articles, which following evaluation against explicit inclusion/exclusion criteria and a quality assessment was reduced to 13 studies. Extracted data from the 13 studies were synthesised using a qualitative approach. Despite the 13 studies being heterogeneous in design, there was consensus on the reasons offenders gave for completion/noncompletion of treatment. The majority were consistent with the factors outlined in the Multifactor Offender Readiness Model (MORM) and included a perceived lack of self-efficacy, negative perceptions of treatment, staff and peers, an inability to regulate emotions, and a lack of perceived choice and control. A lack of opportunity to engage in established, professionally run, groups, as well as perceived inadequate support from members of staff, was also associated with poor engagement and noncompletion of treatment.
对被拘留的成年罪犯未能参加或成功完成治疗项目的原因进行了系统综述。对文献的初步检索共识别出2827篇文章,在根据明确的纳入/排除标准进行评估以及质量评估后,最终缩减至13项研究。采用定性方法对这13项研究中提取的数据进行了综合分析。尽管这13项研究在设计上存在异质性,但罪犯给出的完成/未完成治疗的原因存在共识。大多数原因与多因素罪犯准备模型(MORM)中概述的因素一致,包括自我效能感不足、对治疗、工作人员和同伴的负面看法、无法调节情绪以及缺乏选择和控制感。缺乏参与既定的、专业开展的团体的机会,以及认为工作人员的支持不足,也与参与度低和未完成治疗有关。