Sahebi Ali, Jahangiri Katayoun, Sohrabizadeh Sanaz, Golitaleb Mohamad
Department of Health in Disasters and Emergencies, School of Public Health and Safety, Shahid Beheshti University of Medical Sciences, Tehran, Iran.
Safety Promotion and Injury Prevention Research Center, Shahid Beheshti University of Medical Sciences, Tehran, Iran.
Iran J Psychiatry. 2019 Oct;14(4):325-334.
Workplace violence is one type of occupational hazards that is increasingly growing worldwide. In the health system, one of the important groups subject to workplace violence is emergency medical services (EMS) personnel, who provide emergency services for patients and casualties as the first responders. The aim of this study was to determine the prevalence of workplace violence and its different types among Iranian EMS personnel. This study was conducted based on PRISMA guideline for systematic review and meta-analysis. The data were extracted from Scopus, PubMed, Web of Science, Google Scholar, SID and MagIran databases using Persian and English keywords. The search was conducted up to December 2018 without any limitation in publication year. The qualities of selected papers were assessed by STROBE checklist. I index was used to evaluate heterogeneity, and random effects model was used in meta-analysis. Data were analyzed using Stata14. A total of 9 studies entered the meta-analysis. The total sample size was 1257 Iranian EMS personnel, with an average age of 32.21 ± 2.01 years. The prevalence of physical, verbal, and cultural workplace violence among EMS personnel was 36.39% (CI 95%:27.29-45.50, P<0.001, I = 90.8%), 73.13% (95% CI=68.64-77.62, P=0.013, I = 62.7%), and 16.51% (95% CI =3.49- 29.53, p<0.001. I = 94.7%), respectively. Considering the high prevalence of workplace violence among EMS personnel in Iran, more studies should be conducted to determine the underlying causes of EMS staff workplace violence in Iran. Training violence prevention methods as well as assigning national protective rules are highly suggested. Insufficient studies on Workplace violence among EMS personnel in Iran and high heterogeneity were the limitations of this study.
工作场所暴力是一种在全球范围内日益增多的职业危害。在卫生系统中,遭受工作场所暴力的一个重要群体是紧急医疗服务(EMS)人员,他们作为第一响应者为患者和伤亡人员提供紧急服务。本研究的目的是确定伊朗EMS人员中工作场所暴力的患病率及其不同类型。 本研究是根据PRISMA系统评价和荟萃分析指南进行的。使用波斯语和英语关键词从Scopus、PubMed、科学网、谷歌学术、SID和MagIran数据库中提取数据。搜索截至2018年12月,对出版年份没有任何限制。通过STROBE清单评估所选论文质量。使用I指数评估异质性,并在荟萃分析中使用随机效应模型。使用Stata14分析数据。 共有9项研究进入荟萃分析。总样本量为1257名伊朗EMS人员,平均年龄为32.21±2.01岁。EMS人员中身体暴力、言语暴力和文化暴力的患病率分别为36.39%(95%CI:27.29 - 45.50,P<0.001,I = 90.8%)、73.13%(95%CI = 68.64 - 77.62,P = 0.013,I = 62.7%)和16.51%(95%CI = 3.49 - 29.53,p<0.001,I = 94.7%)。 考虑到伊朗EMS人员中工作场所暴力的高患病率,应开展更多研究以确定伊朗EMS工作人员工作场所暴力的潜在原因。强烈建议培训预防暴力方法并制定国家保护规则。伊朗EMS人员工作场所暴力研究不足以及异质性高是本研究的局限性。