Silman A J, Petrie J, Hazleman B, Evans S J
Department of Clinical Epidemiology, London Hospital Medical College.
Ann Rheum Dis. 1988 Dec;47(12):988-92. doi: 10.1136/ard.47.12.988.
Two hundred and two patients with rheumatoid arthritis (RA) starting treatment with large doses of azathioprine (median 300 mg/day) between 1964 and 1974 were followed up until March 1984. All but one patient (99.5%) were traced from either hospital or general practice records; and death certificates, where relevant, were obtained. A comparison group of 202 patients with RA not treated with azathioprine was selected from the diagnostic index of another rheumatology unit and followed up in 1985 to assess their status retrospectively at March 1984. Each patient treated with azathioprine was matched for year of birth, year of diagnosis, sex, and serostatus with a control patient from the latter group. Four lymphoproliferative cancers occurred in the azathioprine treated group compared with two in the control group. Further analysis of these findings suggested an increased risk of lymphoma of one case per 1000 patient years of azathioprine treatment. The lymphoma rates were then compared with those expected based on the incidence in the general population. This comparison suggested a fivefold increase in the RA control group and a 10-fold increase in the azathioprine treated group. There was also an excess of patients with non-lymphoproliferative cancers, including one with myeloma in the azathioprine group (29 v 19), the excess being greater in the group with the longest duration of treatment. This significantly increased risk did not, however, persist on matched analysis, was not related to maximum daily dose, and was not site specific. These results from a possibly unique series of patients treated with high dose azathioprine give some reassurance about the magnitude of the previously postulated carcinogenic risk of such treatment in RA.
1964年至1974年间开始接受大剂量硫唑嘌呤(中位剂量300毫克/天)治疗的202例类风湿关节炎(RA)患者被随访至1984年3月。除1例患者外(99.5%),所有患者均通过医院或全科医疗记录追踪;并在相关情况下获取了死亡证明。从另一个风湿病科的诊断索引中选取了202例未接受硫唑嘌呤治疗的RA患者作为对照组,并于1985年进行随访,以回顾性评估他们在1984年3月时的状况。接受硫唑嘌呤治疗的每位患者均与后一组中的对照患者在出生年份、诊断年份、性别和血清学状态方面进行匹配。硫唑嘌呤治疗组发生了4例淋巴增殖性癌症,而对照组为2例。对这些结果的进一步分析表明,每1000患者年的硫唑嘌呤治疗会使淋巴瘤风险增加1例。然后将淋巴瘤发生率与基于一般人群发病率预期的发生率进行比较。这种比较表明,RA对照组增加了5倍,硫唑嘌呤治疗组增加了10倍。非淋巴增殖性癌症患者也有多余,包括硫唑嘌呤组中的1例骨髓瘤患者(29例对19例),治疗时间最长的组中多余情况更明显。然而,在匹配分析中,这种显著增加的风险并未持续存在,与最大日剂量无关,也不具有部位特异性。这些来自可能独特的一组接受高剂量硫唑嘌呤治疗患者的结果,对于先前推测的这种治疗在RA中的致癌风险程度提供了一些安慰。