Bonazza Nicholas A, Riboh Jonathan C
Duke Sports Science Institutes, Department of Orthopaedic Surgery, Duke University Medical Center, Durham, NC, USA.
Curr Rev Musculoskelet Med. 2020 Apr;13(2):164-172. doi: 10.1007/s12178-020-09612-4.
Recurrent shoulder instability after stabilization is common in pediatric and adolescent athletes. The purpose of this review is to understand the risk factors that lead to failure of primary surgery and management principles in the setting of recurrent instability following surgical stabilization.
Rates of recurrence after primary and revision surgical stabilization remain higher than desirable. Risk factors for failure in include glenoid and humeral bone loss, capsular or ligamentous laxity, and young age though few studies have focused specifically on the adolescent population. Arthroscopic, open, and bone block techniques have been described in this population similar to adults. Failure after a primary shoulder stabilization remains a common problem in adolescents in no small part because a high proportion of these athletes return to high levels of activity. A thorough understanding of the index procedure and patient-specific risk factors for failure are key to successful planning of revision surgery. The current literature does not allow for firm treatment recommendations in individual pediatric or adolescent athletes, but the guiding principles are similar to those in adults. Specifically, all bony and soft tissue pathology should be identified and assessed, with an understanding that simply repeating the steps of the index procedure typically results in poor outcomes, and often an "escalation" of surgical complexity is required at the time of revision. When appropriately indicated, arthroscopic or open soft tissue procedures and Latarjet coracoid transfer can be safely and successfully implemented for revision shoulder stabilization in young athletes.
在儿童和青少年运动员中,稳定手术后复发性肩关节不稳定很常见。本综述的目的是了解导致初次手术失败的危险因素以及手术稳定后复发性不稳定情况下的处理原则。
初次手术和翻修手术稳定后的复发率仍高于预期。失败的危险因素包括肩胛盂和肱骨骨质流失、关节囊或韧带松弛以及年龄较小,不过很少有研究专门针对青少年人群。在这一人群中,已描述了与成人相似的关节镜、开放和骨块技术。初次肩关节稳定术后失败在青少年中仍然是一个常见问题,很大程度上是因为这些运动员中有很大比例会恢复到高水平活动。透彻了解初次手术步骤和患者特定的失败危险因素是成功规划翻修手术的关键。目前的文献无法为个别儿童或青少年运动员提供确切的治疗建议,但指导原则与成人相似。具体而言,应识别和评估所有骨和软组织病变,要明白简单重复初次手术步骤通常会导致不良结果,而且翻修时往往需要提高手术复杂性。在适当的情况下,关节镜或开放软组织手术以及拉塔热喙突转移术可安全、成功地用于年轻运动员翻修肩关节稳定手术。