Borracci Raúl Alfredo, Ciambrone Graciana, Gallesio José María Alvarez
School of Medicine, Buenos Aires University, Buenos Aires, Argentina.
Medical Education Research Laboratory, Hospital Alemán, Buenos Aires, Argentina.
J Educ Eval Health Prof. 2020 Jan;17:6. doi: 10.3352/jeehp.2020.17.6. Epub 2020 Feb 18.
Moral courage is the conviction to take action on one's ethical beliefs despite the risk of adverse consequences.. It aimed to evaluate the correlation between social desirability score and moral courage scores of medical residents and fellows, and to explore gender and specialty-based differences of moral courage scores.
In April 2018, the Moral Courage Scale for Physicians (MCSP), the Professional Moral Courage (PMC) scale and the Marlowe-Crowne scale to measure social desirability were administered to 87 medical residents from Hospital Alemán of Buenos Aires, Argentina.
Cronbach's alpha coefficients were 0.78, 0.74 and 0.81 for the Marlowe-Crowne, MCSP and PMC scales, respectively. Correlation analysis showed that moral courage scores were poorly correlated with social desirability scores, while both moral courage scales were highly correlated with each other. Physicians who were training in a surgical specialty showed lower moral courage scores than nonsurgical specialty trainees, and male from any specialty tended to have lower moral courage scores than females. Particularly, individuals performing a surgical specialty ranked lower when assessing "multiple values", "endurance of threats", and "going beyond compliance" dimensions from PMC scale. Male individuals tended to rank lower than females on "multiple values", "moral goals" and "endurance of threats" dimensions.
There was a poor correlation between two validated moral courage scores and social desirability score of the medical residents and fellows in Argentina. Conversely, both moral courage tools showed a good correlation and concordance between them, making these scales reasonably interchangeable.
道德勇气是指尽管存在不良后果的风险,仍坚持根据自己的道德信念采取行动。本研究旨在评估医学住院医师和研究员的社会期望得分与道德勇气得分之间的相关性,并探讨道德勇气得分在性别和专业方面的差异。
2018年4月,对来自阿根廷布宜诺斯艾利斯阿莱曼医院的87名医学住院医师进行了医师道德勇气量表(MCSP)、职业道德勇气(PMC)量表以及用于测量社会期望的马洛-克劳恩量表的测试。
马洛-克劳恩量表、MCSP量表和PMC量表的克朗巴赫α系数分别为0.78、0.74和0.81。相关性分析表明,道德勇气得分与社会期望得分相关性较差,而两个道德勇气量表之间高度相关。接受外科专业培训的医师的道德勇气得分低于非外科专业的受训者,任何专业的男性的道德勇气得分往往低于女性。特别是,在评估PMC量表的“多种价值观”“承受威胁”和“超越合规”维度时,从事外科专业的人员得分较低。在“多种价值观”“道德目标”和“承受威胁”维度上,男性得分往往低于女性。
在阿根廷,医学住院医师和研究员的两个经过验证的道德勇气得分与社会期望得分之间相关性较差。相反,两种道德勇气工具之间显示出良好的相关性和一致性,使得这些量表可以合理互换。