Hassett-Walker Connie, Shadden Mark
Department of Criminal Justice, Kean University, Union, NJ, USA.
Elite Research, LLC, Irving, TX, USA.
Tob Use Insights. 2020 Feb 6;13:1179173X20904350. doi: 10.1177/1179173X20904350. eCollection 2020.
Despite prior studies, transitions in smoking patterns are not fully understood. Getting arrested may alter an individual's smoking pattern through processes proscribed by the criminological labeling theory. This study examined how arrest during emerging adulthood altered smoking behavior during subsequent years and whether there were differential effects by race/ethnicity and gender.
We analyzed 15 waves of data from the National Longitudinal Survey of Youth 1997. Multinomial logistic regressions were performed using Stata software version 14.
For both genders, arrested black men and women had the most distinct smoking transitions (both increases and decreases) as compared with their non-arrested counterparts. Among men, particularly black males, arrest in early adulthood was associated with the men transitioning to both increased and decreased smoking. Patterns in smoking transitions for women were less clear, suggesting that women's smoking may be influenced by factors not in the models. Women had a low probability of starting to smoke or increasing smoking if they were never arrested between 18 and 21 years of age.
The results for transitioning into increased smoking offer some support for labeling theory processes. Other findings suggest that arrest may lead to some men reducing or quitting smoking. Early adulthood arrest may serve to "shock the system" and contribute to males altering their prior smoking behavior.
Tobacco use over the life course, particularly across different racial and ethnic groups, remains understudied. This study contributes to the literature using a nationally representative sample to examine the effect of getting arrested in emerging adulthood on cigarette use during subsequent years. In conducting the study, investigators combined theories and methodological approaches from 2 complementary disciplines: public health and criminal justice. Because criminal justice policymakers tend to focus on issues like ex-offender unemployment, public health officials can provide guidance regarding the effect of justice system involvement on smoking, particularly given the adverse health outcomes of using cigarettes.
尽管之前有过相关研究,但吸烟模式的转变仍未被完全理解。被捕可能会通过犯罪学标签理论所规定的过程改变个人的吸烟模式。本研究考察了成年初期被捕如何在随后几年改变吸烟行为,以及种族/民族和性别是否存在差异影响。
我们分析了1997年全国青年纵向调查的15波数据。使用Stata软件版本14进行多项逻辑回归分析。
对于男女两性而言,与未被捕的同龄人相比,被捕的黑人男性和女性有最明显的吸烟转变(包括增加和减少)。在男性中,尤其是黑人男性,成年早期被捕与吸烟增加和减少的转变都有关。女性吸烟转变的模式不太明确,这表明女性吸烟可能受到模型中未包含的因素影响。如果女性在18至21岁之间从未被捕,那么她们开始吸烟或增加吸烟的可能性较低。
向吸烟增加转变的结果为标签理论过程提供了一些支持。其他研究结果表明,被捕可能导致一些男性减少或戒烟。成年早期被捕可能起到“震动系统”的作用,并促使男性改变他们先前的吸烟行为。
一生中的烟草使用,尤其是不同种族和民族群体之间的烟草使用,仍未得到充分研究。本研究通过使用具有全国代表性的样本,为文献做出了贡献,以考察成年初期被捕对随后几年吸烟行为的影响。在开展这项研究时,研究人员结合了来自两个互补学科的理论和方法:公共卫生和刑事司法。由于刑事司法政策制定者往往关注诸如刑满释放人员失业等问题,公共卫生官员可以就司法系统介入对吸烟的影响提供指导,特别是考虑到吸烟对健康的不良后果。