Department of Neurology, Lariboisière Hospital, Paris Diderot University and INSERM U1141, Paris, France.
Department of Neurology, University Hospital Berne, Berne, Switzerland.
Lancet Neurol. 2020 Mar;19(3):226-233. doi: 10.1016/S1474-4422(20)30004-1.
BACKGROUND: S44819, a selective GABA α5 receptor antagonist, reduces tonic post-ischaemic inhibition of the peri-infarct cortex. S44819 improved stroke recovery in rodents and increased cortical excitability in a transcranial magnetic stimulation study in healthy volunteers. The Randomized Efficacy and Safety Trial of Oral GABA α5 antagonist S44819 after Recent ischemic Event (RESTORE BRAIN) aimed to evaluate the safety and efficacy of S44819 for enhancing clinical recovery of patients with ischaemic stroke. METHODS: RESTORE BRAIN was an international, randomised, double-blind, parallel-group, placebo-controlled, multicentre phase 2 trial that evaluated the safety and efficacy of oral S44189 in patients with recent ischaemic stroke. The study was done in specialised stroke units in 92 actively recruiting centres in 14 countries: ten were European countries (Belgium, Czech Republic, France, Germany, Hungary, Italy, Netherlands, Poland, Spain, and the UK) and four were non-European countries (Australia, Brazil, Canada, and South Korea). Patients aged 18-85 years with acute ischaemic stroke involving cerebral cortex (National Institute of Health Stroke Scale [NIHSS] score 7-20) without previous disability were eligible for inclusion. Participants were randomly assigned to receive 150 mg S44819 twice a day, 300 mg S44819 twice a day, or placebo twice a day by a balanced, non-adaptive randomisation method with a 1:1:1 ratio. Treatment randomisation and allocation were centralised via the interactive web response system using computer-generated random sequences with a block size of 3. Blinding of treatment was achieved by identical appearance and taste of all sachets. Patients, investigators and individuals involved in the analysis of the trial were masked to group assignment. The primary endpoint was the modified Rankin Scale (mRS) score 90 days from onset of treatment, evaluated by shift analysis (predefined main analysis) or by dichotomised analyses using 0-1 versus 2-6 and 0-2 versus 3-6 cutoffs (predefined secondary analysis). Secondary endpoints were the effects of S44819 on the NIHSS and Montreal Cognitive Assessment (MoCA) scores, time needed to complete parts A and B of the Trail Making Test, and the Barthel index. Efficacy analyses were done on all patients who received at least one dose of treatment and had at least one mRS score taken after day 5 (specifically, on or after day 30). Safety was compared across treatment groups for all patients who received at least one dose of treatment. The study was registered at ClinicalTrials.gov, NCT02877615. FINDINGS: Between Dec 19, 2016, and Nov 16, 2018, 585 patients were enrolled in the study. Of these, 197 (34%) were randomly assigned to receive 150 mg S44819 twice a day, 195 (33%) to receive 300 mg S44819 twice a day, and 193 (33%) to receive placebo twice a day. 189 (96%) of 197 patients in the 150 mg S44819 group, 188 (96%) of 195 patients in the 300 mg S44819 group, and 191 (99%) patients in the placebo group received at least one dose of treatment and had at least one mRS score taken after day 5, and were included in efficacy analyses. 195 (99%) of 197 patients in the 150 mg S44819 group, 194 (99%) of 195 patients in the 300 mg S44819 group, and 193 (100%) patients in the placebo group received at least one dose of treatment, and were included in safety analyses. The primary endpoint of mRS at day 90 did not differ between each of the two S44819 groups and the placebo group (OR 0·91 [95% CI 0·64-1·31]; p=0·80 for 150 mg S44819 compared with placebo and OR 1·17 [95% CI 0·81-1·67]; p=0·80 for 300 mg S44819 compared with placebo). Likewise, dichotomised mRS scores at day 90 (mRS 0-2 vs 3-6 or mRS 0-1 vs 2-6) did not differ between groups. Secondary endpoints did not reveal any significant group differences. The median NIHSS score at day 90 did not differ between groups (4 [IQR 2-8] in 150 mg S44819 group, 4 [2-7] in 300 mg S44819 group, and 4 [2-6] in placebo group), nor did the number of patients at day 90 with an NIHSS score of up to 5 (95 [61%] of 156 in 150 mg S44819 group, 106 [66%] of 161 in 300 mg S44819 group, and 104 [66%] of 157 in placebo group) versus more than 5 (61 [39%] in 150 mg S44819 group, 55 [34%] in 300 mg S44819 group, and 53 [34%] in placebo group). Likewise, the median MoCA score (22·0 [IQR 17·0-26·0] in 150 mg S44819 group, 23·0 [19·0-26·5] in 300 mg S44819 group, and 22·0 [17·0-26·0] in placebo group), time needed to complete parts A (50 s [IQR 42-68] in 150 mg S44819 group, 49 s [36-63] in 300 mg S44819 group, and 50 s [38-68] in placebo group) and B (107 s [81-144] in 150 mg S44819 group, 121 s [76-159] in 300 mg S44819 group, and 130 s [86-175] in placebo group) of the Trail Making Test, and the Barthel index (90 [IQR 60-100] in 150 mg S44819 group, 90 [70-100] in 300 mg S44819 group, and 90 [70-100] in placebo group) were similar in all groups. Number and type of adverse events were similar between the three groups. There were no drug-related adverse events and no drug-related deaths. INTERPRETATION: There was no evidence that S44819 improved clinical outcome in patients after ischaemic stroke, and thus S44819 cannot be recommended for stroke therapy. The concept of tonic inhibition after stroke should be re-evaluated in humans. FUNDING: Servier.
背景:S44819 是一种选择性 GABAα5 受体拮抗剂,可减少缺血后peri-infarct 皮质的紧张性抑制。S44819 改善了啮齿动物的中风恢复,并在健康志愿者的经颅磁刺激研究中增加了皮质兴奋性。随机疗效和安全性试验口服 GABAα5 拮抗剂 S44819 后近期缺血事件(RESTORE BRAIN)旨在评估 S44819 增强缺血性中风患者临床康复的安全性和有效性。
方法:RESTORE BRAIN 是一项国际、随机、双盲、平行组、安慰剂对照、多中心 2 期试验,评估了 S44189 在近期缺血性中风患者中的安全性和疗效。该研究在 92 个专门的中风病房进行,分布在 14 个国家的 10 个欧洲国家(比利时、捷克共和国、法国、德国、匈牙利、意大利、荷兰、波兰、西班牙和英国)和 4 个非欧洲国家(澳大利亚、巴西、加拿大和韩国)。符合纳入标准的患者为年龄在 18-85 岁之间、伴有皮质受累的急性缺血性中风(NIHSS 评分 7-20)且无既往残疾的患者。参与者被随机分配接受 150mg S44819 每日两次、300mg S44819 每日两次或安慰剂每日两次,采用 1:1:1 比例的平衡、非适应性随机化方法进行分配。通过使用计算机生成的随机序列和 3 个大小的块大小进行中央化治疗随机化和分配。通过使用相同外观和口感的所有小袋实现治疗的盲法。患者、研究者和参与试验分析的人员均对分组情况进行了盲法。主要终点是治疗开始后 90 天的改良 Rankin 量表(mRS)评分,通过转换分析(预先设定的主要分析)或使用 0-1 与 2-6 和 0-2 与 3-6 截止值的二分分析(预先设定的次要分析)进行评估。次要终点是 S44819 对 NIHSS 和蒙特利尔认知评估(MoCA)评分的影响、完成 Trail Making Test 部分 A 和 B 所需的时间以及 Barthel 指数。所有至少接受一剂治疗且在第 5 天(具体地说,在第 30 天或之后)后至少有一次 mRS 评分的患者进行了疗效分析。所有至少接受一剂治疗的患者均进行了安全性比较。该研究在 ClinicalTrials.gov 上注册,编号为 NCT02877615。
结果:2016 年 12 月 19 日至 2018 年 11 月 16 日期间,共纳入 585 名患者。其中,197 名(34%)患者被随机分配接受 150mg S44819 每日两次、300mg S44819 每日两次或安慰剂每日两次。在 150mg S44819 组的 197 名患者中,有 189 名(96%)患者接受了至少一剂治疗,并且在第 5 天之后(具体地说,在第 30 天或之后)至少有一次 mRS 评分,被纳入疗效分析。在 300mg S44819 组的 195 名患者中,有 188 名(96%)患者接受了至少一剂治疗,并且在第 5 天之后(具体地说,在第 30 天或之后)至少有一次 mRS 评分,被纳入疗效分析。在安慰剂组的 193 名患者中,有 191 名(99%)患者接受了至少一剂治疗,并且在第 5 天之后(具体地说,在第 30 天或之后)至少有一次 mRS 评分,被纳入疗效分析。在 150mg S44819 组的 197 名患者中,有 195 名(99%)患者接受了至少一剂治疗,并且在第 5 天之后(具体地说,在第 30 天或之后)至少有一次 mRS 评分,被纳入安全性分析。在 300mg S44819 组的 195 名患者中,有 194 名(99%)患者接受了至少一剂治疗,并且在第 5 天之后(具体地说,在第 30 天或之后)至少有一次 mRS 评分,被纳入安全性分析。在安慰剂组的 193 名患者中,有 193 名(100%)患者接受了至少一剂治疗,并且在第 5 天之后(具体地说,在第 30 天或之后)至少有一次 mRS 评分,被纳入安全性分析。第 90 天的主要终点 mRS 评分在每个 S44819 组和安慰剂组之间没有差异(S44819 组 0.91 [95%CI 0.64-1.31];与安慰剂相比,OR 1.17 [95%CI 0.81-1.67])。同样,第 90 天的二分类 mRS 评分(mRS 0-2 与 3-6 或 mRS 0-1 与 2-6)在各组之间也没有差异。次要终点未显示出任何显著的组间差异。第 90 天的 NIHSS 中位数在各组之间没有差异(S44819 组 4 [2-8],300mg S44819 组 4 [2-7],安慰剂组 4 [2-6]),第 90 天 NIHSS 评分≤5 的患者比例也没有差异(S44819 组 156 名患者中有 95 名(61%),300mg S44819 组 161 名患者中有 106 名(66%),安慰剂组 157 名患者中有 104 名(66%)),与 NIHSS 评分>5 的患者比例(S44819 组 150 名患者中有 61 名(39%),300mg S44819 组 161 名患者中有 55 名(34%),安慰剂组 157 名患者中有 53 名(34%)))。同样,MoCA 中位数(S44819 组 22.0 [17.0-26.0],300mg S44819 组 23.0 [19.0-26.5],安慰剂组 22.0 [17.0-26.0]),完成 Trail Making Test 部分 A(S44819 组 50 s [42-68],300mg S44819 组 49 s [36-63],安慰剂组 50 s [38-68])和 B(S44819 组 107 s [81-144],300mg S44819 组 121 s [76-159],安慰剂组 130 s [86-175])和 Barthel 指数(S44819 组 90 [60-100],300mg S44819 组 90 [70-100],安慰剂组 90 [70-100])在所有组中均相似。各组的不良事件发生次数和类型相似。无药物相关不良事件和药物相关死亡事件。
结论:S44819 并未改善缺血性中风患者的临床结局,因此不能推荐 S44819 用于中风治疗。人类中风后紧张性抑制的概念应重新评估。
资金来源:Servier。
Bioact Mater. 2024-9-23
J Neurosci. 2023-11-8