Hong Kong Integrated Oncology Centre, Hong Kong, China; Department of Clinical Oncology, Pamela Youde Nethersole Eastern Hospital, Hong Kong, China.
Department of Clinical Oncology, State Key Laboratory of Translational Oncology, Faculty of Medicine, The Chinese University of Hong Kong, Hong Kong, China.
Lung Cancer. 2020 Apr;142:41-46. doi: 10.1016/j.lungcan.2020.02.002. Epub 2020 Feb 11.
NSCLC patients harboring EGFR mutation invariably developed resistance to EGFR TKI. We postulated that oligoresidual disease (ORD) after initial TKI might harbor resistant clones. This study aimed to test if preemptive local ablative therapy (LAT) can improve progression free survival (PFS) or not compared to historic data.
Patients indicated for EGFR TKI who possessed ORD (≤ 4 PET-avid lesions) after an initial 3-month TKI therapy were enrolled. After screening PET-CT, eligible patients with PET-avid ORDs were treated by LAT, either by stereotactic ablative radiotherapy (SABR) or surgery per clinicians' discretion. TKI was continued after LAT until it was considered ineffective. PET-CT was repeated on the 3rd and 12th month post-LAT (or at progression) apart from regular imaging. Further LAT was allowed in oligoprogressive disease. Primary endpoint was PFS rate at one-year from enrollment. Overall survival (OS), PFS and treatment safety were secondary endpoints. A post hoc comparison with screen failure cohort was performed.
Eighteen patients were enrolled from 2014-17. Recruitment was stopped before the planned number (34) due to slow accrual. Two were excluded due to consent withdrawal and significant protocol violation. Median follow up was 39.1 months. Among the 16 analyzed patients, the one-year PFS rate (i.e. 15 month post TKI) was 68.8 %. Median OS was 43.3 months. All LAT were done by SABR, and none experienced ≥ grade 3 SABR related toxicities. Compared with screen failure cohort (n = 48), pre-emptive LAT effectively reduced risk of progression (HR 0.41, p = 0.0097).
Preemptive LAT in ORD appeared to be safe and feasible. The 1-year PFS rate was encouraging. However, potential biases and the limitations of the study should not be overlooked. Further randomized studies are warranted.
携带 EGFR 突变的 NSCLC 患者对 EGFR TKI 不可避免地产生耐药性。我们推测,初始 TKI 后寡残留疾病(ORD)可能存在耐药克隆。本研究旨在检验与历史数据相比,预先局部消融治疗(LAT)是否能改善无进展生存期(PFS)。
入组接受 EGFR TKI 治疗且初始 3 个月 TKI 治疗后存在 ORD(≤4 个 PET 阳性病灶)的患者。在筛选 PET-CT 后,根据医生的判断,对 PET 阳性 ORD 患者进行 LAT 治疗,LAT 包括立体定向消融放疗(SABR)或手术。LAT 后继续使用 TKI,直至认为无效。除常规影像学检查外,在 LAT 后第 3 个月和第 12 个月(或进展时)重复 PET-CT。寡进展性疾病允许进一步 LAT。主要终点为入组后 1 年的 PFS 率。总生存期(OS)、PFS 和治疗安全性为次要终点。进行了与筛选失败队列的事后比较。
2014 年至 2017 年期间共入组 18 例患者。由于入组速度较慢,在计划人数(34 例)之前停止了招募。由于患者撤回同意和严重违反方案,有 2 例被排除。中位随访时间为 39.1 个月。在分析的 16 例患者中,TKI 后 1 年的 PFS 率(即 15 个月时)为 68.8%。中位 OS 为 43.3 个月。所有的 LAT 均由 SABR 完成,无≥3 级 SABR 相关毒性反应发生。与筛选失败队列(n=48)相比,预先 LAT 可有效降低进展风险(HR 0.41,p=0.0097)。
在 ORD 中进行预先 LAT 似乎是安全可行的。1 年 PFS 率令人鼓舞。然而,不应忽视潜在的偏倚和研究的局限性。需要进一步的随机研究。