Medical Education Outcomes, American Medical Association, Chicago, Illinois, USA.
Division of General Medicine and Clinical Epidemiology, University of North Carolina School of Medicine, Chapel Hill, North Carolina, USA.
Teach Learn Med. 2020 Jun-Jul;32(3):241-249. doi: 10.1080/10401334.2020.1724791. Epub 2020 Feb 24.
: Chronic disease is a leading cause of death and disability in the United States. With an increase in the demand for healthcare and rising costs related to chronic care, physicians need to be better trained to address chronic disease at various stages of illness in a collaborative and cost-effective manner. Specific and measurable learning objectives are key to the design and evaluation of effective training, but there has been no consensus on chronic disease learning objectives appropriate to medical student education. Wagner's Chronic Care Model (CCM) was selected as a theoretical framework to guide development of an enhanced chronic disease prevention and management (CDPM) curriculum. Findings of a literature review of CDPM competencies, objectives, and topical statements were mapped to each of the six domains of the CCM to understand the breadth of existing learning topics within each domain. At an in-person meeting, medical educators prepared a survey for the modified Delphi approach. Attendees identified 51 possible learning objectives from the literature review mapping, rephrased the CCM domains as competencies, constructed possible CDPM learning objectives for each competency with the goal of reaching multi-institutional consensus on a limited number of CDPM learning objectives that would be feasible for institutions to use to guide enhancement of medical student curricula related to CDPM. After the meeting, the group developed a survey which included 39 learning objectives. In the study phase of the modified Delphi approach, 32 physician CDPM experts and educators completed an online survey to prioritize the top 20 objectives. The next step occurred at a CDPM interest group in-person meeting with the goal of identifying the top 10 objectives. The CCM domains were reframed as the following competencies for medical student education: patient self-care management, decision support, clinical information systems, community resources, delivery systems and teams, and health system practice and improvement. Eleven CDPM learning objectives were identified within the six competencies that were most important in developing curriculum for medical students. These learning objectives cut across education on the prevention and management of individual chronic diseases and frame chronic disease care as requiring the health system science competencies identified in the CCM. They are intended to be used in combination with traditional disease-specific pathophysiology and treatment objectives. Additional efforts are needed to identify specific curricular strategies and assessment tools for each learning objective.
慢性疾病是导致美国人群死亡和残疾的主要原因。随着对医疗保健需求的增加以及与慢性病护理相关成本的上升,医生需要接受更好的培训,以协作和具有成本效益的方式在疾病的各个阶段处理慢性疾病。具体和可衡量的学习目标是设计和评估有效培训的关键,但对于适合医学生教育的慢性疾病学习目标,尚未达成共识。Wagner 的慢性照护模式 (CCM) 被选为指导增强慢性疾病预防和管理 (CDPM) 课程发展的理论框架。对 CDPM 能力、目标和专题陈述的文献回顾结果被映射到 CCM 的六个领域中的每一个领域,以了解每个领域中现有学习主题的广度。在一次面对面会议上,医学教育工作者为修改后的 Delphi 方法准备了一项调查。与会者从文献综述映射中确定了 51 个可能的学习目标,将 CCM 领域重新定义为能力,为每个能力构建了可能的 CDPM 学习目标,目标是就有限数量的 CDPM 学习目标达成多机构共识,这些目标对于机构来说是可行的,可用于指导与 CDPM 相关的医学生课程的增强。会议结束后,该小组开发了一项调查,其中包括 39 个学习目标。在修改后的 Delphi 方法的研究阶段,32 名医生 CDPM 专家和教育工作者完成了一项在线调查,以确定前 20 个目标的优先级。下一步是在 CDPM 兴趣小组的面对面会议上进行,目标是确定前 10 个目标。CCM 领域被重新定义为医学生教育的以下能力:患者自我护理管理、决策支持、临床信息系统、社区资源、交付系统和团队以及卫生系统实践和改进。在六个能力中确定了 11 个 CDPM 学习目标,这些目标对于为医学生制定课程非常重要。这些学习目标跨越了对个体慢性病的预防和管理的教育,并将慢性病护理框架为需要 CCM 中确定的卫生系统科学能力。它们旨在与传统的疾病特异性病理生理学和治疗目标结合使用。还需要做出更多努力,为每个学习目标确定具体的课程策略和评估工具。