Faculty of Health Sciences, Population Health Sciences, University of Bristol, Bristol, UK.
Queen Mary University of London, London, UK.
Int J Geriatr Psychiatry. 2020 Jun;35(6):662-670. doi: 10.1002/gps.5284. Epub 2020 Mar 9.
Communication of mild cognitive impairment (MCI) diagnoses is challenging due to its heterogeneity and unclear prognosis.
To identify how MCI is communicated and to explore the relationship with patient and companion understanding.
Conversation analysis identified whether MCI was named and explained in 43 video recorded diagnosis feedback meetings. Afterward, patients and companions were asked to name the diagnosis to assess understanding.
Mild cognitive impairment was not named in 21% meetings. Symptoms were explained as (a) a result of vascular conditions (49%), (b) a stage between normal ageing and dementia (30%), or (c) caused by psychological factors (21%). Fifty-four percentage of prognosis discussions included mention of dementia. There was no association between symptom explanations and whether prognosis discussions included dementia. Fifty-seven percentage patients and 37% companions reported not having or not knowing their diagnosis after the meeting. They were more likely to report MCI when prognosis discussions included dementia.
Doctors offer three different explanations of MCI to patients. The increased risk of dementia was not discussed in half the diagnostic feedback meetings. This is likely to reflect the heterogeneity in the definition, cause and likely prognosis of MCI presentations. Clearer and more consistent communication, particularly about the increased risk of dementia, may increase patient understanding and enable lifestyle changes to prevent some people progressing to dementia.
轻度认知障碍 (MCI) 的诊断具有异质性且预后不明确,因此沟通诊断具有挑战性。
确定 MCI 的沟通方式,并探讨其与患者和同伴理解之间的关系。
会话分析确定在 43 个视频记录的诊断反馈会议中是否命名和解释了 MCI。之后,让患者和同伴命名诊断以评估理解程度。
21%的会议未命名 MCI。症状被解释为(a)血管状况的结果(49%)、(b)正常衰老和痴呆之间的阶段(30%)或(c)由心理因素引起(21%)。54%的预后讨论包括提及痴呆。症状解释与是否包括痴呆的预后讨论之间没有关联。57%的患者和 37%的同伴在会议后报告没有或不知道自己的诊断。当预后讨论包括痴呆时,他们更有可能报告 MCI。
医生向患者提供了三种不同的 MCI 解释。一半的诊断反馈会议没有讨论痴呆的风险增加。这可能反映了 MCI 表现的定义、原因和可能的预后存在异质性。更清晰、更一致的沟通,特别是关于痴呆风险增加的沟通,可能会提高患者的理解能力,并促使其改变生活方式,以防止一些人进展为痴呆。