Glaucoma Research Center, Montchoisi Clinic, Swiss Visio Network, Lausanne, Switzerland.
Narayana Nethralaya, Bangalore, Karnataka, India.
J Glaucoma. 2020 Mar;29(3):155-160. doi: 10.1097/IJG.0000000000001430.
Corneal integrity has long been a preoccupation of glaucoma surgeons considering glaucoma drainage device surgery or antimetabolite-enhanced trabeculectomy. Despite having demonstrated a good safety profile and significant intraocular pressure-lowering capacities, the impact of XEN gel stents on endothelial density was never specifically investigated. The purpose of this study is to assess the effect of XEN gel stents on central endothelial cell density (ECD) over 24 months. To achieve this, we compared the effect on ECD of combined XEN surgery with that of a standard phacoemulsification procedure.
This was an investigator-initiated, retrospective study, conducted at a single tertiary glaucoma center. Patients with primary or secondary open-angle glaucoma who underwent XEN implantation combined with phacoemulsification between January 2015 and June 2016 were retrospectively enrolled. Patients who had undergone standalone phacoemulsification over the same period of time were enrolled to form the control group of this comparative study. The primary outcome measure was the ECD. Patients who had undergone standalone XEN implantation and patients for whom both a baseline and 24-month ECD could not be obtained were excluded from the analysis. Percentages of ECD reductions were calculated for each studied eye, and the mean of ECD reductions was calculated for each group as well as for subgroups.
Thirty-two eyes of 23 patients (mean age=76.0±7.9 y, 60% female) underwent standalone phacoemulsification (n=15) or combined XEN surgery (n=17) and had an ECD both at baseline and 24-month postoperatively. Mean baseline ECDs were 2568±491 versus 2379±335 cells/mm, respectively (P=0.21). In the combined XEN surgery group, 58.8% of eyes (n=10) required at least 1 mitomycin C (MMC)-enhanced needling revision to maintain their target intraocular pressure. In the standalone phacoemulsification group, ECD decreased by a mean 14.5%, from 2567.7±491.2 to 2196.1±591.9 cell/mm (P=0.072). In the combined XEN surgery group, ECD decreased by a mean 14.3%, from 2378.8±334.7 to 2039.6±451.1 cell/mm (P=0.018). The difference in percentage reduction of ECD between the 2 groups was not statistically significant (P=0.226). Within the combined XEN surgery group, the ECD decreased by a mean of 15.4% in patients who did not undergo needling revisions and by 13.1% in patients who underwent the MMC-augmented procedure (P=0.485). In the 3 patients who underwent >1 needling revision, a 21.3% reduction in ECD was observed, but the difference was not statistically significant (P=0.653). Neither the time of the first needling (P=0.452), the patients' age (P=0.285), or sex (P=0.308) was statistically associated with ECD loss.
The present study demonstrated that the XEN gel implant combined with phacoemulsification produces 24-month ECD loss of a similar magnitude to that observed following standalone phacoemulsification. MMC-augmented needling revisions do not appear to have an impact on ECD.
考虑到青光眼引流装置手术或抗代谢物增强小梁切除术,角膜完整性一直是青光眼外科医生关注的焦点。尽管已经证明 XEN 凝胶支架具有良好的安全性和显著的降眼压能力,但从未专门研究过 XEN 凝胶支架对内皮细胞密度的影响。本研究旨在评估 XEN 凝胶支架在 24 个月内对中央内皮细胞密度(ECD)的影响。为了实现这一目标,我们比较了 XEN 手术联合与标准超声乳化手术对 ECD 的影响。
这是一项由研究者发起的回顾性研究,在一家三级青光眼中心进行。2015 年 1 月至 2016 年 6 月期间,接受 XEN 植入联合超声乳化的原发性或继发性开角型青光眼患者被回顾性纳入。同期接受单纯超声乳化的患者被纳入本对照研究的对照组。主要观察指标是 ECD。排除仅行 XEN 植入术和无法获得基线及 24 个月 ECD 的患者。计算每个研究眼的 ECD 减少百分比,并计算每组及亚组的 ECD 平均减少量。
23 例患者的 32 只眼(平均年龄 76.0±7.9 岁,60%为女性)接受了单纯超声乳化(n=15)或 XEN 联合手术(n=17),并在基线和术后 24 个月均获得了 ECD。平均基线 ECD 分别为 2568±491 与 2379±335 个细胞/mm(P=0.21)。在 XEN 联合手术组中,58.8%的眼(n=10)需要至少 1 次丝裂霉素 C(MMC)增强针刺修复以维持目标眼压。在单纯超声乳化组中,ECD 平均减少 14.5%,从 2567.7±491.2 降至 2196.1±591.9 个细胞/mm(P=0.072)。在 XEN 联合手术组中,ECD 平均减少 14.3%,从 2378.8±334.7 降至 2039.6±451.1 个细胞/mm(P=0.018)。两组 ECD 减少百分比差异无统计学意义(P=0.226)。在 XEN 联合手术组中,未行针刺修复的患者 ECD 平均减少 15.4%,行 MMC 增强针刺修复的患者 ECD 平均减少 13.1%(P=0.485)。在接受>1 次针刺修复的 3 例患者中,ECD 减少 21.3%,但差异无统计学意义(P=0.653)。第一次针刺的时间(P=0.452)、患者年龄(P=0.285)或性别(P=0.308)均与 ECD 损失无统计学关联。
本研究表明,XEN 凝胶植入物联合超声乳化术可导致 24 个月 ECD 损失,其程度与单纯超声乳化术相似。MMC 增强针刺修复似乎对 ECD 没有影响。