Dong Yang, Peng Shu-Na, Sun Yuan-Ke, Wu Sammy Xiao-Ying, Wang Wei-Sha
Faculty of Education and Science, Jiaying University, Meizhou, China.
Department of Social and Behavioural Sciences, City University of Hong Kong, Kowloon Tong, Hong Kong.
Front Psychol. 2020 Feb 5;10:3037. doi: 10.3389/fpsyg.2019.03037. eCollection 2019.
Metalinguistic knowledge has a facilitative effect on reading comprehension. This meta-analysis examined the relationship between metalinguistic knowledge and reading comprehension among Chinese students. By focusing on both Chinese and English scripts' reading comprehension performance, this study synthesized 46 studies with 73 independent samples that represented 10,793 Chinese students from primary school to university levels. We found that in both Chinese and English scripts' reading, morphological awareness had the strongest correlation with reading comprehension, whereas both phonological awareness and orthographical skill had a similar medium correlation with reading comprehension. All three metalinguistic knowledge, which was not significantly influenced by the selected moderators of grade group, area, language type, and assessment, had an independent correlation with reading comprehension. The results suggested that reading stages did not significantly impact the function of metalinguistic knowledge on both Chinese and English scripts' reading comprehension for Chinese students. In addition, for Chinese students, morphological awareness plays a more important role than phonological awareness and orthographical skill in both Chinese and English scripts' reading comprehension.
元语言知识对阅读理解有促进作用。这项荟萃分析研究了中国学生的元语言知识与阅读理解之间的关系。通过关注中文和英文文本的阅读理解表现,本研究综合了46项研究,涉及73个独立样本,代表了从小学到大学阶段的10793名中国学生。我们发现,在中文和英文文本阅读中,词法意识与阅读理解的相关性最强,而语音意识和正字法技能与阅读理解的相关性中等且相似。所有这三种元语言知识与阅读理解都具有独立相关性,且不受所选年级组、地区、语言类型和评估等调节因素的显著影响。结果表明,阅读阶段对中国学生在中文和英文文本阅读理解中元语言知识的作用没有显著影响。此外,对于中国学生来说,在中文和英文文本阅读理解中,词法意识比语音意识和正字法技能发挥着更重要的作用。