Toronto General Hospital Research Institute, University Health Network, 200 Elizabeth Street, Toronto, Ontario, M5G2C4, Canada.
Women's College Hospital, Toronto, Canada.
BMC Health Serv Res. 2020 Mar 14;20(1):212. doi: 10.1186/s12913-020-05082-z.
Patient-centered care (PCC) is one approach for ameliorating persistent gendered disparities in health care quality, yet no prior research has studied how to achieve patient-centred care for women (PCCW). The purpose of this study was to explore how clinicians deliver PCCW, challenges they face, and the strategies they suggest are needed to support PCCW.
We conducted semi-structured qualitative interviews (25-60 min) with clinicians. Thirty-seven clinicians representing 7 specialties (family physicians, cardiologists, cardiac surgeons, obstetricians/gynecologist, psychiatrists, nurses, social workers) who manage depression (n = 16), cardiovascular disease (n = 11) and contraceptive counseling (n = 10), conditions that affect women across the lifespan. We used constant comparative analysis to inductively analyze transcripts, mapped themes to a 6-domain PCC conceptual framework to interpret findings, and complied with qualitative research reporting standards.
Clinicians said that women don't always communicate their health concerns and physicians sometimes disregard women's health concerns, warranting unique PCC approaches.. Clinicians described 39 approaches they used to tailor PCC for women across 6 PCC domains: foster a healing relationship, exchange information, address emotions/concerns, manage uncertainty, make decisions, and enable self-management. Additional conditions that facilitated PCCW were: privacy, access to female clinicians, accommodating children through onsite facilities, and flexible appointment formats and schedules. Clinicians suggested 7 strategies needed to address barriers of PCCW they identified at the: patient-level (online appointments, transport to health services, use of patient partners to plan and/or deliver services), clinician-level (medical training and continuing professional development in PCC and women's health), and system-level (funding models for longer appointment times, multidisciplinary teamwork to address all PCC domains).
Our research revealed numerous strategies that clinicians can use to optimize PCCW, and health care managers and policy-makers can use to support PCCW through programs and policies. Identified strategies addressed all domains of an established PCC conceptual framework. Future research should evaluate the implementation and impact of these strategies on relevant outcomes such as perceived PCC among women and associated clinical outcomes to prepare for broad scale-up.
以患者为中心的护理(PCC)是改善医疗质量中持续存在的性别差异的一种方法,但之前没有研究探讨如何为女性提供以患者为中心的护理(PCCW)。本研究旨在探讨临床医生如何提供以患者为中心的护理,他们面临的挑战,以及支持以患者为中心的护理所需的建议策略。
我们对 37 名临床医生进行了半结构化定性访谈(25-60 分钟)。这些临床医生代表了 7 个专业领域(家庭医生、心脏病专家、心脏外科医生、妇产科医生/妇科医生、精神科医生、护士、社会工作者),他们管理着抑郁症(n=16)、心血管疾病(n=11)和避孕咨询(n=10),这些条件影响着女性的整个生命周期。我们使用恒定性比较分析对转录本进行了归纳分析,将主题映射到以 6 个域为基础的以患者为中心的护理概念框架中进行解释,并符合定性研究报告标准。
临床医生表示,女性并不总是表达她们的健康问题,而医生有时会忽视女性的健康问题,这需要独特的以患者为中心的护理方法。临床医生描述了 39 种方法,用于在以患者为中心的护理的 6 个领域中为女性量身定制以患者为中心的护理:建立治疗关系、交流信息、解决情绪/问题、管理不确定性、做出决策和促进自我管理。促进以患者为中心的护理的其他条件包括:隐私、获得女性临床医生的支持、通过现场设施照顾孩子、以及灵活的预约格式和时间表。临床医生提出了 7 种需要解决他们在以患者为中心的护理方面所确定的障碍的策略:患者层面(在线预约、交通到医疗服务、使用患者伙伴来规划和/或提供服务)、临床医生层面(医疗培训和以患者为中心的护理和女性健康方面的持续专业发展)和系统层面(用于延长预约时间的资金模式、多学科团队合作以解决所有以患者为中心的护理领域)。
我们的研究揭示了许多临床医生可以用来优化以患者为中心的护理的策略,医疗保健管理者和政策制定者可以通过方案和政策来支持以患者为中心的护理。确定的策略涵盖了既定以患者为中心的护理概念框架的所有领域。未来的研究应该评估这些策略对相关结果的实施和影响,如女性对以患者为中心的护理的感知以及相关的临床结果,为广泛推广做准备。