Department of Forensic Medicine and Imaging, Zurich Institute of Forensic Medicine, University of Zurich, Winterthurerstrasse 190/52, CH-8057, Zurich, Switzerland.
Department of Forensic Genetics, Zurich Institute of Forensic Medicine, University of Zurich, Winterthurerstrasse 190/52, 8057, Zurich, Switzerland.
Forensic Sci Med Pathol. 2020 Jun;16(2):243-251. doi: 10.1007/s12024-020-00234-3. Epub 2020 Mar 13.
As it is unclear if and how long DNA evidence can persist on submerged skin, we examined the potential for recovery of touch DNA and blood stain DNA from skin samples immersed in different aquatic environments and temperatures for forensic purposes in this proof-of-concept study. We used pig skin, either smeared with human blood or held firmly for 30 s by two test-persons, before immersing it in either cold, room-temperature or warm water as well as in a stream and a pond for up to seven days prior to DNA testing. The samples were then typed at 16 STR loci. Cold water samples yielded the most promising results, as shown by the recovery of the full set of 16 reproducible STR loci from the touch DNA sample of one test-person after 7 days. For blood stains, we were able to recover all 16 reproducible STRs after 2 days. Room-temperature water and warm water yielded varying results for both blood stain DNA and touch DNA. For pond and stream samples, DNA recovery was possible only within two days. While the pond and stream samples were at relatively cold temperatures, DNA recovery may have been affected by the presence of water insects and snails in the pond and mud in the stream. Our findings show the potential of using immersed samples, particularly those immersed in cold water, as we could detect a complete DNA profile from blood stains and from touch DNA after several days. Our study opens the way for future in-depth studies, examining larger datasets and a wider range of conditions.
由于目前尚不清楚 DNA 证据在水下环境中是否以及能持续多久,我们在这项概念验证研究中,为了法医目的,检查了从浸入不同水生环境和温度的皮肤样本中恢复接触 DNA 和血痕 DNA 的可能性。我们使用猪皮,在将其浸入冷水、室温或温水以及溪流和池塘中之前,要么涂抹人类血液,要么由两名测试人员紧紧握住 30 秒。在进行 DNA 测试之前,将这些样本浸入水中长达七天。然后,对这些样本进行 16 个 STR 基因座的分型。冷水样本的结果最有希望,因为在浸入水中 7 天后,从一名测试人员的接触 DNA 样本中成功恢复了全套 16 个可重复的 STR 基因座。对于血痕,我们能够在两天内恢复所有 16 个可重复的 STR。对于室温水和温水,血痕 DNA 和接触 DNA 的结果各不相同。对于池塘和溪流样本,只有在两天内才能进行 DNA 回收。虽然池塘和溪流样本的温度相对较低,但 DNA 的恢复可能受到池塘中水生昆虫和蜗牛以及溪流中泥土的存在的影响。我们的研究结果表明,使用浸入式样本(特别是那些浸入冷水中的样本)具有潜力,因为我们可以在数天后从血痕和接触 DNA 中检测到完整的 DNA 图谱。我们的研究为未来更深入的研究开辟了道路,检验更大的数据集和更广泛的条件。