Korte Wilhelm, Merz Constanze, Kirchhoff Felix, Heimeshoff Jan, Goecke Tobias, Beckmann Erik, Kaufeld Tim, Fleissner Felix, Arar Morsi, Schilling Tobias, Haverich Axel, Shrestha Malakh, Martens Andreas
Department of Cardiothoracic, Transplantation and Vascular Surgery, Hannover Medical School, Hannover, Germany.
Interact Cardiovasc Thorac Surg. 2020 Jun 1;30(6):871-878. doi: 10.1093/icvts/ivaa023.
OBJECTIVES: The amount of intense and focused training with the specific goal to improve performance (i.e. deliberate practice) is a predictor of expert-level performance in multiple domains of psychomotor skill learning. Simulation training improves surgical skills in cardiac surgery. We established a training programme that enables early surgical exposure and assessment. We investigated the training effects in coronary surgery simulations in trainees with different levels of surgical experience. METHODS: The early surgical exposure and assessment programme comprises a low- and high-fidelity simulation, self-organized training, instructed workshops and a stepwise challenge increase. Performance was assessed with a multidimensional skill matrix using video recordings. Two groups of trainees [students (N = 7), 1-/2-year residents (N = 6)] completed introductory training (pretraining, level 1) and two 3-week training periods (levels 2 and 3). Fellows (N = 6) served as controls. Residents and students underwent deliberate practice training with specific training targets. Fellows performed regularly scheduled coronary surgery cases. Entry and exit assessments were conducted for levels 2 and 3. RESULTS: Fellows did not improve overall performance. Residents and students showed significant improvements in both technical accuracy and completion times. Residents reached an overall performance level comparable to fellows. Students reached similar accuracy of surgical skills with longer completion times [level 3 exit score/time: fellows 27 (24-29)/min; residents 27 (21-30)/min, P = 0.94; students 17 (17-25)/min, P = 0.068]. CONCLUSIONS: Deliberate practice training resulted in a fast and substantial increase in surgical skills in residents and students. Unexperienced residents reach performance levels of fellows. Deliberate practice simulation programmes should be a mandatory component of surgical training.
目的:以提高表现为特定目标的高强度集中训练(即刻意练习)是多个心理运动技能学习领域中专家级表现的一个预测指标。模拟训练可提高心脏外科手术技能。我们制定了一项培训计划,以实现早期手术接触和评估。我们研究了不同手术经验水平的学员在冠状动脉手术模拟中的训练效果。 方法:早期手术接触和评估计划包括低保真和高保真模拟、自主组织训练、指导工作坊以及逐步增加挑战。使用录像通过多维技能矩阵评估表现。两组学员[学生(N = 7),1/2年级住院医师(N = 6)]完成入门培训(预培训,1级)和两个为期3周的培训阶段(2级和3级)。研究员(N = 6)作为对照组。住院医师和学生接受了针对特定训练目标的刻意练习训练。研究员进行定期安排的冠状动脉手术病例。对2级和3级进行了入门和结业评估。 结果:研究员的整体表现没有提高。住院医师和学生在技术准确性和完成时间方面均有显著提高。住院医师达到了与研究员相当的整体表现水平。学生达到了类似的手术技能准确性,但完成时间更长[3级结业分数/时间:研究员27(24 - 29)/分钟;住院医师27(21 - 30)/分钟,P = 0.94;学生17(17 - 25)/分钟,P = 0.068]。 结论:刻意练习训练使住院医师和学生的手术技能快速且大幅提高。缺乏经验的住院医师达到了研究员的表现水平。刻意练习模拟计划应成为外科培训的一个强制性组成部分。
J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg. 2013-3-15
Ann Thorac Surg. 2017-1
J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg. 2018-2-15
Can J Cardiol. 2021-10
Interdiscip Cardiovasc Thorac Surg. 2024-7-3
Innovations (Phila). 2023
Interact Cardiovasc Thorac Surg. 2022-8-3
Med Sci (Basel). 2022-6-24