Tanskanen Antti O, Danielsbacka Mirkka, Rotkirch Anna
University of Helsinki, Finland.
University of Turku, Finland.
Evol Psychol. 2020 Jan-Mar;18(1):1474704920907894. doi: 10.1177/1474704920907894.
Based on kin selection theory, amounts of grandparental investment should reflect the probability to share common genes with offspring. Adoption may represent a special case, however, yet grandparental investment in adopted children has previously been both theoretically misconstrued and little investigated. Here, we study for the first time how grandparental childcare provision is distributed between biological, adopted, and step-offspring. Using Generations and Gender Surveys ( = 15,168 adult child-grandmother and 12,193 adult child-grandfather dyads) and the Survey of Health, Ageing, and Retirement in Europe ( = 17,233 grandmother-adult child and 13,000 grandfather-adult child dyads), we find that grandparents were less likely to provide care to stepchildren than to adopted and biological children, but no difference between adopted and biological children. These findings were present in both data sets and for both grandmothers and grandfathers, after several potentially confounding factors were taken into account. The stepchild disadvantage is in line with kin selection theory. The congruent amounts of care provided to adopted and biological children may reflect similar levels of adult-child attachment, selection effects, and greater need in adoptive families, as well as some degree of genetical relatedness in the case of kin adoption. The study provides new evidence of biased kin investments in contemporary societies and stresses the importance of psychological motivation and attachment in evolutionary studies of kin investment.
基于亲缘选择理论,祖父母的投资量应反映与孙辈共享共同基因的概率。然而,收养可能是一种特殊情况,此前对收养子女的祖父母投资在理论上存在误解且研究较少。在这里,我们首次研究祖父母的育儿照顾是如何在亲生孩子、收养孩子和继子女之间分配的。利用世代与性别调查(15168对成年子女 - 祖母二元组和12193对成年子女 - 祖父二元组)以及欧洲健康、老龄化和退休调查(17233对祖母 - 成年子女二元组和13000对祖父 - 成年子女二元组),我们发现祖父母照顾继子女的可能性低于收养子女和亲生孩子,但收养子女和亲生孩子之间没有差异。在考虑了几个潜在的混杂因素后,这两个数据集以及祖母和祖父的数据中都出现了这些结果。继子女劣势符合亲缘选择理论。对收养子女和亲生孩子提供的同等照顾量可能反映了成年子女与父母之间相似的依恋水平、选择效应以及收养家庭中更大的需求,以及亲属收养情况下一定程度的基因相关性。该研究为当代社会中存在偏向性的亲缘投资提供了新证据,并强调了心理动机和依恋在亲缘投资进化研究中的重要性。