Singhroy Diane N, MacLean Emily, Kohli Mikashmi, Lessem Erica, Branigan David, England Kathleen, Suleiman Khairunisa, Drain Paul K, Ruhwald Morten, Schumacher Samuel, Denkinger Claudia M, Waning Brenda, Van Gemert Wayne, Pai Madhukar
McGill International TB Centre, McGill University, Montreal, QC, H4B1X5, Canada.
Department of Epidemiology, Biostatistics, and Occupational Health, McGill University, Montreal, QC, Canada.
Gates Open Res. 2020 Apr 7;4:24. doi: 10.12688/gatesopenres.13112.2. eCollection 2020.
Since 2015, the World Health Organization (WHO) has recommended a commercially available lateral-flow urine LAM test (Alere-LAM) to assist in the diagnosis of tuberculosis (TB) in severely ill people living with HIV (PLHIV). The test can rapidly detect TB in severely ill PLHIV and can identify PLHIV most at-risk of death, leading to mortality reductions. However, its uptake in countries with high burdens of TB and HIV has been slow. To assess the current use landscape and identify barriers to the adoption of Alere-LAM, we conducted a questionnaire-based study in 31 high TB and HIV/AIDS burden countries. : Between November 2018 and December 2019, we collected responses to a semi-structured questionnaire that had been emailed to staff and affiliates of National TB Programs or HIV/AIDS Programs, Ministries of Health, and TB or HIV institutes of 31 high TB/HIV burden countries. Questions concerned country policies, adoption, and current use of Alere-LAM testing, as well as testing algorithms and barriers preventing Alere-LAM uptake. We received questionnaire responses from 24 out of 31 (77%) high TB/HIV burden countries. Of these 24 countries, 11 (46%) had adopted Alere-LAM policies, with only five (21%) countries currently using Alere-LAM testing. Testing algorithms were generally aligned with WHO recommendations. Fifteen countries (63%) said they were planning to implement Alere-LAM testing in the near future. The most commonly cited constraint to adoption and implementation was budget limitations. Additional barriers to Alere-LAM implementation included lack of country-specific data and piloting, administrative hurdles such as regulatory agency approval, lack of coordination between National TB and HIV programs, and small perceived patient population. Responses to our questionnaire demonstrate the persistent gap between country-level policy and real-world use of Alere-LAM, as well as specific barriers that must be addressed to scale-up testing in PLHIV.
自2015年以来,世界卫生组织(WHO)推荐了一种市售的侧向流动尿液脂阿拉伯甘露聚糖(LAM)检测(Alere-LAM),以协助诊断重症HIV感染者(PLHIV)中的结核病(TB)。该检测可快速检测重症PLHIV中的结核病,并能识别死亡风险最高的PLHIV,从而降低死亡率。然而,它在结核病和HIV负担较重的国家的采用速度一直很慢。为了评估当前的使用情况并确定采用Alere-LAM的障碍,我们在31个结核病和HIV/AIDS负担较重的国家进行了一项基于问卷调查的研究。在2018年11月至2019年12月期间,我们收集了对一份半结构化问卷的回复,该问卷已通过电子邮件发送给31个结核病/艾滋病高负担国家的国家结核病项目或HIV/AIDS项目的工作人员和附属机构、卫生部以及结核病或HIV研究所。问题涉及国家政策、Alere-LAM检测的采用和当前使用情况,以及检测算法和阻碍Alere-LAM采用的障碍。我们收到了31个结核病/艾滋病高负担国家中24个国家(77%)的问卷回复。在这24个国家中,11个国家(46%)采用了Alere-LAM政策,目前只有5个国家(21%)使用Alere-LAM检测。检测算法总体上与WHO的建议一致。15个国家(63%)表示他们计划在不久的将来实施Alere-LAM检测。采用和实施最常提到的限制因素是预算限制。Alere-LAM实施的其他障碍包括缺乏针对特定国家的数据和试点、行政障碍(如监管机构批准)、国家结核病和HIV项目之间缺乏协调以及认为患者群体较小。我们问卷的回复表明,国家层面的政策与Alere-LAM的实际使用之间存在持续差距,以及在PLHIV中扩大检测规模必须解决的具体障碍。