College of Architecture and Environment & Healthy Food Evaluation Research Center, Sichuan University, Chengdu, 610065, China; Key Laboratory of Environment Remediation and Ecological Health (Zhejiang University), Ministry of Education, Hangzhou, 310058, China.
Collaborative Innovation Center of Mine Environmental Rehabilitation, Lanzhou Resources & Environment Voc-Tech College, Lanzhou, 730021, China.
Environ Res. 2020 May;184:109300. doi: 10.1016/j.envres.2020.109300. Epub 2020 Feb 27.
Soils in large areas of China are enriched in fluorine (F). The present study analyzed F concentrations in cultivated soil, water, chemical fertilizer, and human hair, and metal concentrations in soils from an endemic fluorosis area in Southwest, China. In order to reveal the effects of industry on F concentration in the environment, 3 towns mainly with agriculture production and another 3 towns with developed phosphorus chemical industry in a same city were selected for sample collection. The total F concentrations of the 277 surface agricultural soil samples were 378.79-1576.13 μg g, and F concentrations of nearly 95% of the soil samples were higher than the Chinese average topsoil F concentration (480 μg g). Only a small fraction (0.75%) of total F was water soluble. The average total F, water soluble F, Ca, Cr, Fe, K, Mn, Rb, and Sr concentrations in soil samples from towns with intensive industry were higher than those from towns mainly with agriculture. Significant correlations were found between soil pH with total F (p < 0.01) and with water soluble F concentration (p < 0.1). Low F concentrations (<0.5 mg L) were found in irrigation water, well water and tap water in a town where the industry is dense. The phosphorus fertilizer and compound fertilizer had hundreds of times of contribution to soil F increment than the nitrogen fertilizer and potassium fertilizer. Nearly half percent of F in the human hair samples was of exogenic origin. Based on soil ingestion pathway, the health risk for adults exposure to F in soils was acceptable, however, F may pose possible health risks to children in high F concentration areas.
中国大部分地区的土壤富含氟(F)。本研究分析了中国西南地区地方性氟中毒地区土壤、水、化肥和人发中的氟浓度以及土壤中的金属浓度。为了揭示工业对环境中氟浓度的影响,选择了一个城市中 3 个主要以农业生产为主的镇和另外 3 个磷化工发达的镇进行采样。277 个表层农业土壤样品的总 F 浓度为 378.79-1576.13μg g,近 95%的土壤样品的 F 浓度高于中国表层土壤 F 平均浓度(480μg g)。只有一小部分(0.75%)总 F 是水溶性的。工业密集镇土壤样品中的总 F、水溶性 F、Ca、Cr、Fe、K、Mn、Rb 和 Sr 浓度平均值高于主要以农业为主的镇。土壤 pH 值与总 F(p<0.01)和水溶性 F 浓度(p<0.1)呈显著正相关。在一个工业密集的城镇,灌溉水、井水和自来水的 F 浓度均较低(<0.5mg L)。与氮、钾肥相比,磷肥和复合肥对土壤 F 增加的贡献高达数百倍。人发样品中近 5%的 F 来自外源性。基于土壤摄入途径,成年人暴露于土壤 F 的健康风险是可以接受的,然而,在高 F 浓度地区,F 可能对儿童构成潜在健康风险。