Trovato F
Dept. of Sociology, University of Alberta, Edmonton, Canada.
Cult Med Psychiatry. 1988 Dec;12(4):459-77. doi: 10.1007/BF00054498.
Mortality differentials reflect in part the social and economic conditions of groups in society. In this paper, the relationship between ethnic origin and mortality is investigated from the point of view of convergence and minority group status hypotheses. Multivariate methods are used to study differences among the French, the British and Native Indian (includes Metis and Eskimos) populations of Canada over three census periods from 1951 to 1971. A significant downward trend in the death rates of all three subpopulations is noted, but substantial differences persist, as the pace of mortality decline over time varies across the three ethnic groups. In the twenty-year interval between 1951 and 1971, Native Indians have experienced spectacular reductions in their overall death rates, but in comparative terms, their mortality levels still exceed those of the French (who show intermediate levels) and the British ethnic groups. The multivariate analysis provides strong support for the minority status effect, which is taken to suggest that the roots of inequalities in survival probabilities are partly a result of social and economic disparities. The convergence thesis received some support: over time the general pattern is one of declining mortality with some narrowing of the differences. An examination of four broad causes of death (neoplasms, cardiovascular, accidents-violence, and "other") suggests that Native Indians are characteristic of populations undergoing epidemiologic and demographic transitions. Their elevated risk of accidents-violence reflects social disruption in the process of modernization. Causes of death of the French and British populations are characterized by higher risks of cancer and cardiovascular diseases, typical of advanced societies.
死亡率差异部分反映了社会群体的社会和经济状况。本文从趋同和少数群体地位假说的角度研究了种族出身与死亡率之间的关系。运用多变量方法研究了1951年至1971年三个普查时期加拿大的法裔、英裔和印第安原住民(包括梅蒂斯人和因纽特人)人口之间的差异。注意到所有这三个亚群体的死亡率都有显著的下降趋势,但由于三个种族群体随时间的死亡率下降速度不同,巨大差异仍然存在。在1951年至1971年的20年期间,印第安原住民的总体死亡率大幅下降,但相比之下,他们的死亡率水平仍然超过法裔(处于中等水平)和英裔群体。多变量分析为少数群体地位效应提供了有力支持,这表明生存概率不平等的根源部分是社会和经济差距造成的。趋同论点得到了一些支持:随着时间的推移,总体模式是死亡率下降,差异有所缩小。对四类主要死因(肿瘤、心血管疾病、事故-暴力和“其他”)的研究表明,印第安原住民具有正在经历流行病学和人口结构转变的人口特征。他们较高的事故-暴力风险反映了现代化进程中的社会混乱。法裔和英裔人口的死因特征是患癌症和心血管疾病的风险较高,这是发达社会的典型特征。