Southwestern Academic Limb Salvage Alliance (SALSA), Department of Surgery, Keck School of Medicine of University of Southern California, Los Angeles, USA.
J Foot Ankle Res. 2020 Mar 24;13(1):16. doi: 10.1186/s13047-020-00383-2.
In 2007, we reported a summary of data comparing diabetic foot complications to cancer. The purpose of this brief report was to refresh this with the best available data as they currently exist. Since that time, more reports have emerged both on cancer mortality and mortality associated with diabetic foot ulcer (DFU), Charcot arthropathy, and diabetes-associated lower extremity amputation.
We collected data reporting 5-year mortality from studies published following 2007 and calculated a pooled mean. We evaluated data from DFU, Charcot arthropathy and lower extremity amputation. We dichotomized high and low amputation as proximal and distal to the ankle, respectively. This was compared with cancer mortality as reported by the American Cancer Society and the National Cancer Institute.
Five year mortality for Charcot, DFU, minor and major amputations were 29.0, 30.5, 46.2 and 56.6%, respectively. This is compared to 9.0% for breast cancer and 80.0% for lung cancer. 5 year pooled mortality for all reported cancer was 31.0%. Direct costs of care for diabetes in general was $237 billion in 2017. This is compared to $80 billion for cancer in 2015. As up to one-third of the direct costs of care for diabetes may be attributed to the lower extremity, these are also readily comparable.
Diabetic lower extremity complications remain enormously burdensome. Most notably, DFU and LEA appear to be more than just a marker of poor health. They are independent risk factors associated with premature death. While advances continue to improve outcomes of care for people with DFU and amputation, efforts should be directed at primary prevention as well as those for patients in diabetic foot ulcer remission to maximize ulcer-free, hospital-free and activity-rich days.
2007 年,我们报告了一项糖尿病足并发症与癌症数据比较的总结。本简要报告的目的是用当前最佳可用数据对此进行更新。自那时以来,关于癌症死亡率以及与糖尿病足溃疡(DFU)、夏科氏关节病和糖尿病相关下肢截肢相关的死亡率的更多报告已经出现。
我们收集了 2007 年后发表的报告 5 年死亡率数据,并计算了汇总平均值。我们评估了 DFU、夏科氏关节病和下肢截肢的数据。我们将高截肢和低截肢分别定义为踝部以上和以下。这与美国癌症协会和国家癌症研究所报告的癌症死亡率进行了比较。
夏科氏病、DFU、小截肢和大截肢的 5 年死亡率分别为 29.0%、30.5%、46.2%和 56.6%,而乳腺癌的死亡率为 9.0%,肺癌的死亡率为 80.0%。所有报告癌症的 5 年汇总死亡率为 31.0%。2017 年,糖尿病一般护理的直接费用为 2370 亿美元。相比之下,2015 年癌症的直接费用为 800 亿美元。由于糖尿病下肢并发症的直接护理费用高达三分之一可能归因于下肢,因此这些费用也很容易比较。
糖尿病下肢并发症仍然带来巨大负担。最值得注意的是,DFU 和 LEA 似乎不仅仅是健康状况不佳的标志。它们是与过早死亡相关的独立危险因素。虽然不断取得进展,以改善 DFU 和截肢患者的护理结果,但应将努力方向不仅放在初级预防上,还应放在糖尿病足溃疡缓解患者的预防上,以最大限度地提高无溃疡、无住院和活动丰富的天数。