Mattos Sandra da Silva, Moser Lúcia Roberta Didier Nunes, Diogenes Tereza Cristina Pinheiro, Severi Rossana, de Araújo Juliana Sousa Soares, Albuquerque Fernanda Cruz de Lira, Tavare Thiago Ribeiro, Mourato Felipe Alves
Heart Circle from Pernambuco, Recife, Brazil.
Telemed J E Health. 2020 Dec;26(12):1449-1454. doi: 10.1089/tmj.2019.0196. Epub 2020 Mar 26.
Congenital heart disease (CHD) affects 1% of all newborns and is a major public health problem. Most children with CHD benefit from early diagnosis to optimize management. However, in many places there are no specialized professionals to do so. A screening method for CHD was developed between two states in Northeast Brazil. It was based upon the performance of an echocardiogram by local pediatricians with support of pediatric cardiologists through telemedicine. To determine if the continuous performance of examinations together with online supervision increased the level of understanding of the pediatricians about the echocardiograms. Pediatricians received online support to perform echocardiograms for 7 years (2012-2018). Although the project aimed to teach them to acquire images and send to the cardiologists for analysis and interpretation, they were encouraged to describe their own diagnostic impressions. The level of agreement between pediatricians and cardiologists was calculated. A large number ( = 3,951) echocardiograms was analyzed. From them, 2,818 were classified as abnormal, inconclusive, or normal by both the pediatricians and the cardiologists. The 7-year analysis demonstrated an overall agreement of 63.7%. As for the final diagnosis, it was possible to compare 1,457 echocardiograms. The combined analysis of the 7 years demonstrated agreement in 62.2%. The screening of CHD under online support led to more in-depth learning of echocardiography by the pediatricians. This approach potentialized the accuracy of the screening through the years. By enrolling in a telemedicine-based screening program, the pediatricians' degree of understanding of echocardiography increased considerably.
先天性心脏病(CHD)影响着1%的新生儿,是一个重大的公共卫生问题。大多数先天性心脏病患儿受益于早期诊断以优化治疗管理。然而,在许多地方没有专业人员来进行早期诊断。巴西东北部两个州开发了一种先天性心脏病筛查方法。该方法基于当地儿科医生在儿科心脏病专家通过远程医疗的支持下进行超声心动图检查。目的是确定持续进行检查并辅以在线监督是否能提高儿科医生对超声心动图的理解水平。儿科医生在7年(2012 - 2018年)里接受在线支持来进行超声心动图检查。尽管该项目旨在教他们获取图像并发送给心脏病专家进行分析和解读,但也鼓励他们描述自己的诊断印象。计算了儿科医生和心脏病专家之间的一致性水平。分析了大量(= 3951份)超声心动图。其中,2818份被儿科医生和心脏病专家都归类为异常、不确定或正常。7年的分析显示总体一致性为63.7%。至于最终诊断,对1457份超声心动图进行了比较。7年的综合分析显示一致性为62.2%。在在线支持下进行先天性心脏病筛查使儿科医生对超声心动图有了更深入的学习。多年来,这种方法提高了筛查的准确性。通过参加基于远程医疗的筛查项目,儿科医生对超声心动图的理解程度有了显著提高。