Tanaka T, Kobayashi T
Department of Neurosurgery, Nagoya University School of Medicine, Japan.
No Shinkei Geka. 1988 Jun;16(7):845-50.
Thirty-three cases of craniopharyngioma in children for past twenty-two years were evaluated by long term result, the outcome by different treatment, the effect of irradiation and recurrence rate, etc. Operation was performed in all cases. The contents of operation were as follows: total removal; 3 cases, subtotal removal; 9 cases, partial removal; 11 cases, cyst evacuation + Ommaya reservoir; 9 cases, shunt only; 1 case. Ten cases were operated by transsphenoidal approach, five cases of which were performed by combined operation of intracranial and transsphenoidal approach and extensive removal was possible in all cases. Radiation therapy was carried out in seventeen cases, four of which were treated by internal irradiation with Au-198 colloid or P-32 chromic phosphate. Overall survival rates of 5 years and 10 years were 70% and 64% respectively. The more the grade of tumor removal was done, the lower the rate of death resulted. In five cases treated by combined operation of intracranial and transsphenoidal approach, all cases were surviving. In irradiated group 5 year and 10 year survival rates were 93% and 71.5%, while, in non-irradiated group those survival rates were 46.2% and 46.2% respectively. Internal irradiation was done in four cases, the effect of which was satisfactory. Recurrences of the tumor appeared in eight cases, three of which were dead. In conclusion; 1) Overall survival rates of 5 years and 10 years were 70% and 64% respectively. The rate of tumor removal was well correlated to the outcome. 2) The outcome in the irradiated group was better than that in nonirradiated group.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)
对过去22年里33例儿童颅咽管瘤病例进行了长期结果评估,包括不同治疗方式的结果、放疗效果及复发率等。所有病例均接受了手术。手术内容如下:全切3例,次全切9例,部分切除11例,囊肿排空+Ommaya贮液器9例,单纯分流1例。10例采用经蝶窦入路手术,其中5例采用颅内与经蝶窦联合入路手术,所有病例均可行广泛切除。17例进行了放射治疗,其中4例采用198金胶体或32磷铬酸盐进行内照射。5年和10年总生存率分别为70%和64%。肿瘤切除程度越高,死亡率越低。在5例采用颅内与经蝶窦联合入路手术治疗的病例中,所有病例均存活。放疗组5年和10年生存率分别为93%和71.5%,而未放疗组分别为46.2%和46.2%。4例进行了内照射,效果满意。8例出现肿瘤复发,其中3例死亡。结论:1)5年和10年总生存率分别为70%和64%。肿瘤切除率与结果密切相关。2)放疗组的结果优于未放疗组。(摘要截短至250字)