Mindus P, Nyman H, Rosenquist A, Rydin E, Meyerson B A
Department of Psychiatry and Psychology, Karolinska Hospital, Stockholm, Sweden.
Acta Neurochir Suppl (Wien). 1988;44:138-44. doi: 10.1007/978-3-7091-9005-0_27.
Capsulotomy is an established psychosurgical intervention for anxiety disorders. While the effectiveness of the intervention in reducing target symptoms is undisputed, the issue of negative personality changes following capsulotomy is of great concern. We studied prospectively personality traits in nine consecutive patients undergoing capsulotomy for anxiety disorder, using the Rorschach test and a personality inventory, the Karolinska Scales of Personality (KSP), administered before and one year after operation. The protocols were evaluated under blind conditions by an independent assessor who had access to no data other than the age and sex of the patients. The Rorschach findings were used in two main comparison procedures: between the patients pre- and postoperative scores, and between that group and three reference groups. The KSP data were compared both with an age-stratified non-patient control group and with data obtained from groups of neurotic patients. In summary, the capsulotomy patients' personalities, as expressed in their Rorschach interpretations, remained intact, and significant reductions were noted in scales reflecting anxiety and hospitality. Statistically significant changes were also noted after operation in 10 of the 17 scales included in the KSP. While pathological scores were observed preoperatively in many scales, all the postoperative scores but one (Socialization) were within the normal range. Scores on the Socialization scale remained low, which is often the case in chronic patients. It is concluded that the patients displayed more normal personality features after operation than before and that adverse personality changes are not likely to occur after capsulotomy.
囊切开术是一种针对焦虑症的既定精神外科干预措施。虽然该干预措施在减轻目标症状方面的有效性无可争议,但囊切开术后负面人格改变的问题备受关注。我们对连续9例因焦虑症接受囊切开术的患者进行了前瞻性人格特质研究,在手术前和术后一年使用罗夏测验和一种人格量表——卡罗林斯卡人格量表(KSP)。这些方案由一名独立评估者在盲态条件下进行评估,该评估者除了患者的年龄和性别外无法获取其他任何数据。罗夏测验结果用于两个主要比较程序:患者术前和术后得分之间的比较,以及该组与三个参照组之间的比较。KSP数据既与按年龄分层的非患者对照组进行比较,也与从神经症患者组获得的数据进行比较。总之,从罗夏测验解释中所表现出的囊切开术患者的人格保持完整,并且在反映焦虑和随和性的量表上有显著降低。在KSP所包含的17个量表中,术后也有10个量表出现了具有统计学意义的变化。虽然术前在许多量表上观察到病理得分,但除一个量表(社会化)外,所有术后得分均在正常范围内。社会化量表得分仍然较低,这在慢性病患者中很常见。结论是,患者术后比术前表现出更正常的人格特征,并且囊切开术后不太可能发生不良人格改变。