Jang Young-Eun, Kim Nam-Hee
Department of Dental Hygiene, The Graduate School, Yonsei University, Seoul, Wonju, Republic of Korea.
Department of Dental Hygiene, Wonju College of Medicine, Yonsei University, Wonju, Republic of Korea.
Indian J Dent Res. 2020 Jan-Feb;31(1):57-60. doi: 10.4103/ijdr.IJDR_212_18.
Independent dental hygiene practice is critical in regions with low accessibility to dental services, as well as for preventing and managing oral diseases among children and the elderly from low-income families, as these individuals are highly vulnerable to oral diseases.
We investigated whether the job autonomy of dental hygienists has been maintained, in accordance with the guidelines of the International Federation of Dental Hygienists (IFDH).
This study comprised a cross-sectional literature review.
We reviewed national reports and articles published in 23 countries selected for analysis to determine the degree of dental hygienist job autonomy, based on the extent of dental hygiene education. We divided the countries into two groups, based on the historical length of dental hygienist education.
We classified education as direct access, indirect supervision, and direct supervision. Two researchers reviewed and revised the classification results to ensure reliability. The Kappa value was 0.96 points. Statistical analysis was performed by PASW statistics 23.0 program (SPSS Inc., Chicago, IL, USA.).
Countries with >40 years of educating dental hygienists exhibited more independent dental hygienist practices than those with less than 40 years of educating dental hygienists.
Countries with >40 years of experience in educating dental hygienists largely guarantee independent dental hygiene practice for dental hygienists, in accordance with IFDH guidelines. The society's need for dental hygienists is fulfilled and professional competency is maintained in these contexts; thus, it should be required for dental hygienists to maintain independent dental hygiene practices.
在牙科服务可及性较低的地区,独立的口腔卫生保健实践至关重要,对于预防和管理低收入家庭儿童及老年人的口腔疾病也很关键,因为这些人群极易患口腔疾病。
我们根据国际口腔卫生保健员联合会(IFDH)的指南,调查口腔卫生保健员的工作自主性是否得到了维持。
本研究包括一项横断面文献综述。
我们审查了为分析而选定的23个国家发表的国家报告和文章,根据口腔卫生保健教育的程度来确定口腔卫生保健员工作自主性的程度。我们根据口腔卫生保健员教育的历史时长将这些国家分为两组。
我们将教育分类为直接准入、间接监督和直接监督。两名研究人员对分类结果进行了审查和修订,以确保可靠性。卡帕值为0.96分。统计分析由PASW statistics 23.0程序(美国伊利诺伊州芝加哥市SPSS公司)进行。
培养口腔卫生保健员超过40年的国家比培养口腔卫生保健员少于40年的国家表现出更多独立的口腔卫生保健实践。
根据IFDH指南,培养口腔卫生保健员有超过40年经验的国家在很大程度上保证了口腔卫生保健员的独立口腔卫生保健实践。在这些情况下,社会对口腔卫生保健员的需求得到了满足,专业能力也得以维持;因此,应要求口腔卫生保健员维持独立的口腔卫生保健实践。