Faculty of Health and Sport Sciences, University of Tsukuba, Tsukuba, Japan.
Department of Physical Performance, Norwegian School of Sport Sciences, Oslo, Norway.
J Mot Behav. 2021;53(2):191-199. doi: 10.1080/00222895.2020.1748860. Epub 2020 Apr 7.
This study compares polyrhythmic production ability between water polo players (WPs), artistic swimmers (ASs) and drummers (Ds), to assess how their differing experiences in coordinating complex inter-limb activity with music affected this ability. Eight ASs, eight WPs and eight Ds participated. They were asked to perform finger and foot taps in a single-rhythm task (every 750 ms) and two polyrhythmic tasks (finger and foot taps at 750 and 500 ms, respectively, and vice versa). The percentage of correct response cycles (PCRC), subjective difficulty scores were collected and analysed using a two-way mixed analysis of variance (ANOVA) and coefficients of variation of the inter-tap interval (CV) were collected and analysed using a three-way mixed analysis of variance (ANOVA). The three groups showed no statistically significant differences in the single-rhythm task. However, on polyrhythmic tasks, the WPs were significantly outperformed by the other two groups in PCRC and CV. These results suggest that the experience of coordinating limbs with music has positive impacts on polyrhythmic production ability. They also imply that ASs and Ds have similar polyrhythmic production ability despite the apparent differences in task complexity in their daily training and performances.
本研究比较了水球运动员(WPs)、艺术游泳运动员(ASs)和鼓手(Ds)的复节奏产生能力,以评估他们在协调复杂肢体活动与音乐方面的不同经验如何影响这种能力。八名 ASs、八名 WPs 和八名 Ds 参与了研究。他们被要求在单节奏任务(每 750ms)和两个复节奏任务(手指和脚分别在 750ms 和 500ms 时敲击,反之亦然)中进行手指和脚的敲击。收集和分析了正确反应循环百分比(PCRC)和主观难度得分,并使用双向混合方差分析(ANOVA)进行分析,同时收集和分析了敲击间隔的变异系数(CV),并使用三向混合方差分析(ANOVA)进行分析。三组在单节奏任务中没有表现出统计学上的显著差异。然而,在复节奏任务中,WPs 在 PCRC 和 CV 方面明显逊于其他两组。这些结果表明,协调肢体与音乐的经验对复节奏产生能力有积极影响。它们还表明,尽管 ASs 和 Ds 在日常训练和表演中的任务复杂性明显不同,但他们具有相似的复节奏产生能力。