Myerholtz Linda, Baker Hannah M, Rollins Lisa, Page Cristen
Department of Family Medicine, University of North Carolina, Chapel Hill.
Lineberger Comprehensive Cancer Center, University of North Carolina, Chapel Hill.
Fam Med. 2020 Apr;52(4):262-269. doi: 10.22454/FamMed.2020.225169.
The Accreditation Council for Graduate Medical Education requires soliciting learner feedback on faculty teaching, although gathering meaningful feedback is challenging in the medical education environment. We developed the Faculty Feedback Facilitator (F3App), a mobile application that allows for real-time capture of narrative feedback by residents. The purpose of our study was to assess efficacy, usability, and acceptability of the F3App in family medicine residency programs.
Residents, faculty, and program directors (PDs) from eight residency programs participated in a beta test of the F3App from November 2017 to May 2018; participants completed pre- and postimplementation surveys about their evaluation process and the F3App. We interviewed PDs, and analyzed responses using a thematic analysis approach.
Survey results showed significant postimplementation increases in faculty agreement that accessing evaluations is easy (42%), evaluations are an effective way to communicate feedback (34%), feedback is actionable and meaningful (24%), and the current system provides meaningful data for promotion (33%). Among residents, agreement that the current system allows meaningful information sharing and is easy to use increased significantly, by 17% each. The proportion of residents agreeing they were comfortable providing constructive criticism increased significantly (22%). PDs generally reported that residents were receptive to using the F3App, found it quick and easy to use, and that feedback provided was meaningful.
Participating programs reviewed the F3App positively as a tool to gather narrative feedback from learners on faculty teaching.
毕业后医学教育认证委员会要求征集学员对教师教学的反馈意见,尽管在医学教育环境中收集有意义的反馈具有挑战性。我们开发了教师反馈促进应用程序(F3App),这是一款移动应用程序,可让住院医师实时收集叙述性反馈。我们研究的目的是评估F3App在家庭医学住院医师培训项目中的有效性、可用性和可接受性。
来自8个住院医师培训项目的住院医师、教师和项目主任在2017年11月至2018年5月期间参与了F3App的测试版;参与者完成了关于他们的评估过程和F3App的实施前和实施后调查。我们采访了项目主任,并采用主题分析方法分析了回复。
调查结果显示,实施后教师在以下方面的认同度显著提高:评估易于获取(42%)、评估是传达反馈的有效方式(34%)、反馈具有可操作性且有意义(24%)以及当前系统为晋升提供有意义的数据(33%)。在住院医师中,认为当前系统允许有意义的信息共享且易于使用的认同度显著提高,均提高了17%。同意能够自如提供建设性批评的住院医师比例显著增加(22%)。项目主任普遍报告称,住院医师愿意使用F3App,认为它快速且易于使用,并且提供的反馈有意义。
参与项目对F3App给予了积极评价,认为它是一种从学员那里收集关于教师教学的叙述性反馈的工具。