University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, MI, USA.
Case Western Reserve University, Cleveland, OH, USA.
Trauma Violence Abuse. 2021 Dec;22(5):1316-1325. doi: 10.1177/1524838020915592. Epub 2020 Apr 10.
The current study sought to review the state of existing knowledge on rural maltreatment.
We conducted a scoping literature review to answer two research questions: (1) Is maltreatment higher in rural areas compared to urban areas? and 2) Are there unique correlates of maltreatment in rural areas?
This review included studies that compared child maltreatment in rural and urban areas in the United States (9) and predictors of maltreatment in rural areas (7).
Studies that compared child maltreatment in rural and urban areas in the United States were included. For our second research question, related to understanding maltreatment in rural areas, we included those studies that exclusively examined rural areas, when maltreatment was the outcome variable.
Studies were reviewed from relevant databases (, , , ) between 1975 and 2019.
Findings were mixed on whether rates of maltreatment were higher or lower in rural areas. While five studies reported higher rates of maltreatment in rural areas, four reported higher rates in urban areas. Overall, child maltreatment rates tended to be higher in urban areas among people of color and higher in rural areas among White people. One study found that community economic factors were not related to maltreatment in a rural area, in stark contrast to robust findings from urban areas.
本研究旨在回顾农村虐待问题的现有知识状况。
我们进行了范围界定文献综述,以回答两个研究问题:(1)与城市地区相比,农村地区的虐待情况更严重吗?(2)农村地区是否存在独特的虐待相关因素?
本综述包括在美国比较农村和城市地区儿童虐待情况的研究(9 项)和农村地区虐待预测因素的研究(7 项)。
纳入了在美国比较农村和城市地区儿童虐待情况的研究。对于我们的第二个研究问题,即了解农村地区的虐待问题,我们纳入了那些专门研究农村地区、将虐待作为结果变量的研究。
对 1975 年至 2019 年间的相关数据库( , , , )进行了研究审查。
农村地区虐待率较高还是较低的结果喜忧参半。五项研究报告称农村地区的虐待率较高,四项研究报告称城市地区的虐待率较高。总体而言,在有色人种中,城市地区的儿童虐待率往往较高,而在白人中,农村地区的虐待率较高。一项研究发现,农村地区的社区经济因素与虐待无关,这与城市地区的有力发现形成鲜明对比。