Department of Computer Science, University of Toronto, Toronto, Ontario, Canada.
Department of Radiology, Stanford University Hospital, Palo Alto, California.
J Am Coll Radiol. 2020 Sep;17(9):1149-1158. doi: 10.1016/j.jacr.2020.03.012. Epub 2020 Apr 9.
The aim of this study was to enhance multispecialty CT and MRI protocol assignment quality and efficiency through development, testing, and proposed workflow design of a natural language processing (NLP)-based machine learning classifier.
NLP-based machine learning classification models were developed using order entry input data and radiologist-assigned protocols from more than 18,000 unique CT and MRI examinations obtained during routine clinical use. k-Nearest neighbor, random forest, and deep neural network classification models were evaluated at baseline and after applying class frequency and confidence thresholding techniques. To simulate performance in real-world deployment, the model was evaluated in two operating modes in combination: automation (automated assignment of the top result) and clinical decision support (CDS; top-three protocol suggestion for clinical review). Finally, model-radiologist discordance was subjectively reviewed to guide explainability and safe use.
Baseline protocol assignment performance achieved weighted precision of 0.757 to 0.824. Simulating real-world deployment using combined thresholding techniques, the optimized deep neural network model assigned 69% of protocols in automation mode with 95% accuracy. In the remaining 31% of cases, the model achieved 92% accuracy in CDS mode. Analysis of discordance with subspecialty radiologist labels revealed both more and less appropriate model predictions.
A multiclass NLP-based classification algorithm was designed to drive local operational improvement in CT and MR radiology protocol assignment at subspecialist quality. The results demonstrate a simulated workflow deployment enabling automated assignment of protocols in nearly 7 of 10 cases with very few errors combined with top-three CDS for remaining cases supporting a high-quality, efficient radiology workflow.
本研究旨在通过开发、测试和提出基于自然语言处理(NLP)的机器学习分类器的工作流程设计,提高多学科 CT 和 MRI 协议分配的质量和效率。
使用来自日常临床使用中获得的超过 18000 个独特 CT 和 MRI 检查的订单输入数据和放射科医生分配的协议,开发基于 NLP 的机器学习分类模型。k-最近邻、随机森林和深度神经网络分类模型在基线和应用类别频率和置信度阈值技术后进行了评估。为了模拟实际部署中的性能,该模型在两种操作模式下进行了评估:自动化(自动分配最佳结果)和临床决策支持(CDS;为临床审查提供前三名的协议建议)。最后,对模型-放射科医生的不一致性进行主观审查,以指导可解释性和安全使用。
基线协议分配性能达到 0.757 至 0.824 的加权精度。使用联合阈值技术模拟实际部署,优化后的深度神经网络模型在自动化模式下分配 69%的协议,准确率为 95%。在其余 31%的情况下,模型在 CDS 模式下达到 92%的准确率。与专科放射科医生标签的不一致性分析显示,模型的预测既有更多也有更少的恰当之处。
设计了一种多类 NLP 分类算法,以在专科放射学协议分配方面推动 CT 和 MRI 局部运营改进,达到专科质量水平。结果表明,一种模拟工作流程的部署能够在近 7 个案例中的近 7 个案例中实现协议的自动分配,并且很少出现错误,同时对于其余案例提供前三名的 CDS,支持高质量、高效的放射学工作流程。